In my experience as a professional sommelier and brewer, I have come across various types of cocktail shakers. When it comes to choosing between a standard shaker and a Boston shaker, there are a few factors to consider. Let's delve into the details and explore the pros and cons of each.
1. Capacity: One of the primary differences between a standard shaker and a Boston shaker is their capacity. A Boston shaker typically has a larger volume, allowing you to mix a larger quantity of ingredients at once. This is particularly advantageous in a busy bar setting where efficiency is crucial. On the other hand, a standard shaker usually has a smaller capacity, which may be more suitable for home use when you are making cocktails for a few people.
2. Speed and Efficiency: When it comes to speed and efficiency, Boston shakers have a clear advantage. The two-piece design of a Boston shaker allows for a quick and seamless shake, reducing the time it takes to mix ingredients. This is especially beneficial in a high-volume bar, where bartenders need to churn out cocktails quickly. Standard shakers, with their built-in strainers and caps, may take a bit longer to assemble and disassemble, causing a slight delay in the cocktail-making process.
3. Durability: In terms of durability, Boston shakers tend to be more robust. Made from stainless steel or glass, they are less prone to breakage or wear and tear. Standard shakers, with their built-in strainers and caps, have more moving parts, which can potentially lead to leakage or malfunction over time. However, with proper care, both types of shakers can last a long time.
4. Ease of Use: When it comes to ease of use, standard shakers have the upper hand. They are typically user-friendly, with built-in strainers and caps that eliminate the need for additional tools. This makes them ideal for home bartenders who may not have a wide array of bar accessories at their disposal. Boston shakers, on the other hand, require a separate strainer to be used alongside the shaker itself, which can be a bit more cumbersome for beginners.
Personal Recommendation:
Based on my personal experiences and observations, I would recommend a Cobbler Shaker for home use. It strikes a good balance between capacity and ease of use. Unless you are planning to make cocktails in large volumes, a Cobbler Shaker should suffice for your home bar needs. Its built-in strainer and cap make it convenient to use, and you won't have to worry about investing in additional tools.
While both standard shakers and Boston shakers have their merits, professional bartenders often prefer Boston shakers due to their larger capacity, speed, and efficiency. However, for home use, a Cobbler Shaker is a more practical choice, offering ease of use and convenience. Ultimately, the choice between a standard shaker and a Boston shaker depends on your specific needs and circumstances.