When it comes to finding a substitute for Tuaca Italian liqueur, there are a few options that can provide a similar flavor profile. One option is to look for straight vanilla liqueurs. Brands such as Bols and DeKuyper offer vanilla liqueurs that are not spiced, providing a pure vanilla taste. These liqueurs can be used as a substitute for Tuaca to add a touch of sweetness and vanilla flavor to cocktails or desserts.
Another alternative is to use vanilla vodka or rum instead of Tuaca. Many brands offer sweetened options of vanilla vodka or rum that are bottled at 35 percent ABV (70 proof). These sweetened spirits can provide a similar flavor to Tuaca, with the added benefit of being versatile in a variety of cocktails.
Personally, I have used vanilla vodka as a substitute for Tuaca in a few cocktail recipes, and it worked quite well. The vanilla flavor was prominent, and it added a touch of sweetness to the drink. However, it is important to note that the alcohol content may vary between brands, so it's best to choose a vanilla vodka or rum that matches the ABV of Tuaca (35 percent ABV or 70 proof) for the closest match.
If you're looking for a non-spiced alternative to Tuaca Italian liqueur, consider using straight vanilla liqueurs from brands like Bols or DeKuyper. Alternatively, vanilla vodka or rum can also be used as substitutes, as long as they are sweetened and bottled at 35 percent ABV (70 proof). Experimenting with these options can help you find the perfect substitute for Tuaca in your cocktails or desserts.