When it comes to substituting Averna, there are several other dark, herbal and sweet amaros that can be used. While Averna is a popular choice, it's always good to have alternatives on hand to suit your taste preferences or if you simply don't have Averna available.
One option is Meletti, another Italian amaro that shares similar characteristics with Averna. Meletti has a rich and complex flavor profile with notes of herbs, spices, and gentle sweetness. It can be used as a one-to-one substitute for Averna in cocktails or enjoyed neat over ice. Personally, I find Meletti to be slightly milder and less bitter compared to Averna, making it a great option for those who prefer a smoother taste.
Another alternative is Nonino, an Italian amaro that is known for its versatility in cocktails. Nonino is made from a blend of herbs and aged in oak barrels, resulting in a deep and complex flavor profile. It has a slightly more pronounced herbal character compared to Averna, with hints of bitter orange, nutmeg, and vanilla. Nonino works well as a substitute for Averna in cocktails like the Paper Plane, where its bold flavors can complement the other ingredients.
If you're looking for a different twist, you can consider Amaro Tosolini as a substitute for Averna. This Italian amaro is made from a blend of over 15 herbs and botanicals, resulting in a robust and aromatic flavor profile. Amaro Tosolini offers a slightly sweeter profile compared to Averna, with notes of caramel, dark chocolate, and bitter orange. It can add depth and complexity to cocktails like the Brooklyn, or be enjoyed on its own as a digestif.
Lastly, Cynar is another intriguing option. While it may not be as similar to Averna in terms of sweetness, it still falls under the category of dark, herbal amaros. Cynar is made primarily from artichoke leaves, giving it a unique vegetal flavor. It has a bittersweet taste with hints of caramel and herbal undertones. Cynar can be used as a substitute for Averna in cocktails that can benefit from its distinctive flavor, such as the classic Negroni or Boulevardier.
Ultimately, the choice of substitute for Averna will depend on your personal taste preferences and the specific cocktail you're making. It's always fun to experiment with different amaros to discover new flavor combinations and find your own favorites. So, don't be afraid to explore and try different options to see which one suits your palate best. Cheers!