As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the pleasure of tasting and comparing various whiskeys, including Jameson and Proper No. Twelve. Each of these whiskeys has its own unique taste profile, and I'll try to describe the differences as accurately as possible.
Proper No. Twelve has a sweeter taste profile compared to Jameson. When you take a sip of Proper No. Twelve, you'll immediately notice the presence of ripe fruit flavors. The whiskey offers a distinct fruity sweetness that can remind you of juicy peaches or plums. This sweetness is balanced by subtle notes of caramel, which adds a depth of flavor to the whiskey. Additionally, Proper No. Twelve has a noticeable oak spice, which provides a warm and slightly peppery sensation on the palate.
On the other hand, Jameson has a smoother and more well-rounded taste. When you taste Jameson, you'll first notice a hint of vanilla, which adds a creamy and slightly sweet note to the whiskey. This subtle sweetness is complemented by toasted wood flavors, which give off a pleasant and comforting aroma. Jameson also has a balanced flavor profile, where no single aspect dominates, allowing you to enjoy a harmonious blend of flavors.
In terms of overall sweetness, Proper No. Twelve leans more towards the sweeter side, while Jameson offers a more balanced and nuanced taste. Both whiskeys possess their own unique characteristics and can be appreciated by whiskey enthusiasts with different preferences.
To illustrate my point, let me share a personal experience. I recently had the opportunity to enjoy a glass of Proper No. Twelve while sitting by a cozy fireplace on a cold winter evening. The sweetness of the whiskey, coupled with the fruity notes, created a delightful and comforting experience. It felt like a warm embrace, providing a sense of relaxation and enjoyment.
On another occasion, I savored a glass of Jameson during a whiskey tasting event. The smoothness and balance of the whiskey allowed me to focus on the subtle nuances of flavor. The vanilla and toasted wood notes, in particular, stood out, and I found myself appreciating the craftsmanship that went into creating such a well-rounded whiskey.
Proper No. Twelve offers a sweeter taste profile with prominent notes of ripe fruit, caramel, and oak spice. It provides a more pronounced and fruit-forward experience. On the other hand, Jameson presents a smoother and more balanced taste, with hints of vanilla, toasted wood, and a subtle sweetness. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on your personal preference for sweetness and fruitiness versus a well-balanced and nuanced flavor.