What is the difference between Chardonnay and Buttery Chardonnay?

Answered by Brandon Riddell

Chardonnay is a versatile and widely popular grape varietal that is grown in many regions around the world. It is known for producing a range of styles, from crisp and unoaked to rich and oaked. One of the distinct styles of Chardonnay is the buttery Chardonnay, which is characterized by its creamy texture and flavors of vanilla, butter, and even caramel.

The main difference between Chardonnay and buttery Chardonnay lies in the winemaking process and the influence of oak. Chardonnay grapes themselves do not naturally possess these buttery characteristics, but they develop during the winemaking process.

To make buttery Chardonnay, winemakers typically use oak for fermentation and aging. The oak barrels impart flavors and aromas to the , creating a rich and creamy mouthfeel. The oak also adds additional complexity to the wine, with notes of vanilla, toast, and sometimes even caramel.

The type of oak used can also influence the flavor profile of the buttery Chardonnay. French oak tends to give more nuanced flavors, while American oak can contribute stronger vanilla and coconut flavors. The length of time the wine spends in the oak barrels also affects the intensity of the oaky characteristics.

The climate in which the Chardonnay grapes are grown also plays a role in the flavor profile. Cool climate Chardonnays, such as those from regions like Chablis in France or the Sonoma Coast in California, tend to have more citrus flavors. The cool climate helps to preserve the acidity in the grapes, resulting in a wine that is crisp and refreshing despite the oaky and buttery characteristics.

On the other hand, warm climate Chardonnays, like those from regions such as Napa Valley in California or Margaret River in Australia, often exhibit more tropical fruit flavors. The warmer temperatures allow the grapes to fully ripen, resulting in wines with ripe pineapple, mango, and peach flavors.

It's important to note that not all Chardonnays are buttery. In fact, many Chardonnays are made in a more minimalist style, with little to no oak influence. These unoaked Chardonnays showcase the natural flavors and characteristics of the grape, often displaying crisp acidity, green apple, and citrus notes.

Ultimately, the choice between Chardonnay and buttery Chardonnay comes down to personal preference. Some wine drinkers enjoy the richness and complexity of a buttery Chardonnay, while others prefer a lighter, more fruit-forward style. Exploring different styles and regions can be a fun and educational journey, allowing you to discover the nuances and diversity within the world of Chardonnay.