As an expert sommelier and brewer, I can confidently say that using regular ice for an Old Fashioned is not ideal. Let me explain why.
When it comes to cocktails, including the classic Old Fashioned, the type of ice used can greatly impact the overall experience. Bagged grocery store ice, also known as regular ice, is typically made using a quick freezing process. This results in ice cubes that are small, porous, and melt quickly.
One of the key aspects of an Old Fashioned is the balance of flavors. The combination of whiskey, sugar, bitters, and any additional ingredients should come together harmoniously. However, if you use regular ice that melts quickly, it can dilute the drink more rapidly, causing the flavors to become watered down. This can significantly affect the taste and enjoyment of the cocktail.
To avoid this, it is recommended to use larger ice cubes when making an Old Fashioned. Using a large ice cube has become the standard for serving this classic cocktail. The larger ice cube melts at a slower rate, allowing you to savor the flavors of the drink for a longer period of time. It also helps maintain the desired temperature without excessively diluting the cocktail.
Now, let's discuss the process of preparing an Old Fashioned using regular ice. First, you would need to stir the ingredients together in a mixing glass. However, due to the quick-melting nature of regular ice, it is best to stir only briefly. This will help minimize the amount of dilution that occurs during the mixing process.
Once the ingredients are combined and briefly stirred, it is important to strain the cocktail into a rocks glass over fresh ice. This step is crucial because it allows you to remove any small ice shards or excess water that may have formed during the stirring process. By straining the drink, you ensure a cleaner and more enjoyable drinking experience.
While it is technically possible to use regular ice for an Old Fashioned, it is not the ideal choice. Regular ice melts quickly and can easily water down the cocktail, affecting the balance of flavors. To fully appreciate the complexity of an Old Fashioned, it is recommended to use larger ice cubes that melt at a slower rate. This will help maintain the integrity of the drink and enhance your overall enjoyment.