Basil Hayden Bourbon is a decent bourbon, but in my opinion, it falls short of being considered a truly great bourbon. It has its merits, but at a price point of around $50, I believe there are better options available that offer more flavor and complexity.
One of the main reasons I feel this way is that I find Basil Hayden to be quite mild and lacking in depth compared to other bourbons in a similar price range. While it is smooth and easy to drink, it doesn't have the bold flavors and rich character that I look for in a bourbon. It tends to be on the lighter side, with subtle notes of vanilla, caramel, and spice, but these flavors don't quite shine through as much as I would like.
I have tried Basil Hayden on multiple occasions, both neat and in cocktails, and while it is certainly enjoyable, it doesn't leave a lasting impression on me. I find myself craving more complexity and depth of flavor that other bourbons in its price range can provide.
That being said, taste is subjective, and there are certainly people who enjoy the milder and smoother profile of Basil Hayden. It may be a good option for those who prefer a more subtle and approachable bourbon. However, for someone like me who appreciates bold and robust flavors, Basil Hayden falls short of delivering that experience.
In terms of value for money, I personally feel that Basil Hayden is overpriced. There are plenty of bourbons available at a lower price point that offer a more satisfying and flavorful experience. For around $25-30, you can find bourbons that provide a similar level of quality and taste, if not better.
While Basil Hayden Bourbon is not a bad bourbon by any means, I believe there are better options available at a more reasonable price. If you're looking for a bourbon with more flavor and complexity, I would suggest exploring other options in the market before settling on Basil Hayden.