As an expert sommelier and brewer, I can provide you with a detailed answer to your question about whether Benchmark Full Proof is the same as Stagg Jr. Let's dive into the specifics.
First and foremost, it's important to note that both Benchmark Full Proof and Stagg Jr. are produced by Buffalo Trace Distillery. This means that they come from the same distillery and are made using the same high-quality ingredients and production methods. However, there are some differences between the two expressions.
One of the key differences lies in the age and proof of the whiskey. Benchmark Full Proof is aged for at least 4 years, whereas Stagg Jr. is typically aged for around 8-9 years. This difference in aging can have a significant impact on the flavor profile of the whiskey. Older whiskies tend to have more complex flavors and a smoother finish.
In terms of proof, Benchmark Full Proof is bottled at a standard 125 proof, while Stagg Jr. is bottled at barrel proof, which can range from 125-140 proof. This means that Stagg Jr. is bottled straight from the barrel without any dilution, giving it a higher alcohol content and potentially more intense flavors.
However, despite these differences in age and proof, both Benchmark Full Proof and Stagg Jr. share the same mashbill, known as Buffalo Trace's LOW Rye mashbill. This mashbill is composed primarily of corn, with a smaller percentage of malted barley and a lower amount of rye compared to other mashbills used by Buffalo Trace. This combination of grains gives the whiskey a unique flavor profile, with hints of sweetness from the corn and a subtle spiciness from the rye.
It's also worth mentioning that Stagg Jr. is part of Buffalo Trace's prestigious Antique Collection, which includes highly sought-after and limited-edition expressions. This collection is known for its exceptional quality and craftsmanship, and Stagg Jr. is no exception. The whiskey has received numerous accolades and is highly regarded among whiskey enthusiasts.
In contrast, Benchmark Full Proof is positioned as a more accessible and affordable option for whiskey lovers. It offers a taste of the same mashbill used in Stagg Jr. and other high-end Buffalo Trace expressions, but at a lower price point.
To summarize, while Benchmark Full Proof and Stagg Jr. share the same mashbill, they differ in terms of age, proof, and overall positioning. Stagg Jr. is a premium, barrel-proof whiskey aged for a longer period of time, while Benchmark Full Proof offers a similar flavor profile at a more affordable price. Both expressions have their own merits and are worth exploring for whiskey enthusiasts.