As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and evaluate a wide range of spirits and beverages, including Buchanan's Deluxe. While it is true that Buchanan's Deluxe has undergone a shift in reputation over the years, it is important to note that the term “top shelf” can be subjective and dependent on individual preferences and market trends.
In the past, Buchanan's was indeed considered a high-end, top-shelf brand. It was often associated with exclusivity and luxury, appealing to those seeking a premium Scotch whisky experience. However, as consumer tastes and trends have evolved, the perception of Buchanan's has shifted, placing it in a category alongside other blended Scotch whiskies such as Dewar's or Cutty Sark.
When evaluating Buchanan's Deluxe, it is important to consider its characteristics and qualities. One notable aspect is its medicinal notes, which can be reminiscent of certain Islay single malts. This adds a unique element to the whisky, giving it a distinct flavor profile. However, it is worth mentioning that these medicinal notes may not appeal to everyone's palate.
In terms of balance, Buchanan's Deluxe showcases a well-rounded and nuanced sweetness and maltiness. This is where it differentiates itself from similar blends like Dewar's White Label. The sweetness is not overpowering, allowing other flavors to shine through and creating a harmonious overall taste.
While some may argue that Buchanan's Deluxe has moved away from its top-shelf status, it is important to recognize that the concept of what constitutes a top-shelf brand can vary over time. As consumer preferences and market dynamics change, certain brands may shift in perception and positioning. This is not unique to Buchanan's, as many other spirits and beverages have experienced similar transitions.
Ultimately, whether Buchanan's Deluxe is considered top shelf or not is subjective and dependent on individual preferences. It is important to taste and evaluate the whisky for yourself, taking into account its unique characteristics, balance of flavors, and personal enjoyment.