As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and evaluate numerous bourbons, including Maker's Mark. Maker's Mark is a well-known and respected brand in the bourbon world, known for its smooth and approachable flavor profile. When it comes to determining whether Maker's Mark is considered a top shelf bourbon, it is important to consider a few key factors.
First and foremost, the term “top shelf” is subjective and can vary depending on individual preferences and tastes. However, in the context of bourbons, top shelf typically refers to higher-end, premium offerings that are often more expensive and crafted with exceptional attention to detail.
In terms of quality, Maker's Mark certainly holds its own. It is a wheated bourbon, which means that a significant portion of the grain bill is composed of wheat instead of the more common choice of rye. This gives Maker's Mark a softer and smoother flavor profile compared to bourbons with a higher rye content. The use of wheat also imparts a slightly sweeter character to the bourbon.
While Maker's Mark is not typically considered a top-tier luxury bourbon like some of the highly sought-after limited releases, it is certainly a step above the average bourbon offerings. The regular version of Maker's Mark can be considered a solid choice for those looking for a reliable and enjoyable bourbon, earning it a “Mid Shelf” rating in my opinion.
However, Maker's Mark also offers a cask strength version, which takes the bourbon to a whole new level. Cask strength bourbons are bottled at their natural, undiluted proof straight from the barrel. This means that the alcohol content can be significantly higher, resulting in a more intense and robust flavor profile.
I recently had the pleasure of trying a batch of Maker's Mark cask strength, and I must say, it truly impressed me. The higher proof amplifies the flavors and adds an extra layer of complexity. The rich caramel and vanilla notes were more pronounced, and the finish was long and satisfying. The cask strength version of Maker's Mark definitely deserves a “Top Shelf” rating in my book.
It is worth mentioning that other well-known wheated bourbons such as the “Pappy” line and the “Weller” line, as well as Larceny, also fall into the top shelf category. These bourbons are highly sought after and often come with a hefty price tag due to their limited availability and exceptional quality.
While Maker's Mark may not be considered a top-tier luxury bourbon, it certainly holds its own in the mid to top shelf range. The regular version of Maker's Mark is a reliable and enjoyable bourbon, earning it a “Mid Shelf” rating. However, the cask strength version takes it to another level, showcasing the brand's commitment to quality and craftsmanship, and deserving a “Top Shelf” rating. Ultimately, the classification of a bourbon as top shelf will vary depending on individual preferences and budget, but Maker's Mark is certainly a brand worth exploring for bourbon enthusiasts.