The Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail that has a rich history and a simple yet sophisticated flavor profile. As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the privilege of exploring and experimenting with various cocktail recipes, including the Old Fashioned. When it comes to the question of whether there is supposed to be a cherry in an Old Fashioned, the answer is not quite straightforward.
Traditionally, the Old Fashioned consists of just a few key ingredients: whiskey (usually bourbon or rye), bitters, sugar, and a twist of citrus peel. This minimalist approach allows the spirit to take center stage, with the other elements working harmoniously to enhance its flavors. In its purest form, the Old Fashioned does not include any garnishes such as cherries.
However, over time, the cocktail has evolved, and different variations have emerged. Some variations do indeed include a cherry as a garnish. This addition can add a touch of sweetness and a pop of color to the drink. While not part of the original recipe, the cherry garnish has become a popular addition in many bars and households.
It's important to note that the addition of a cherry is a matter of personal preference. Some purists argue that the cherry detracts from the simplicity and elegance of the original drink, while others enjoy the added sweetness and aesthetic appeal it provides. Ultimately, the decision to include a cherry in an Old Fashioned is up to the individual making or ordering the drink.
In my experience, I have seen both versions of the Old Fashioned being served. I have personally enjoyed the classic version without a cherry, savoring the rich flavors of the whiskey and the subtle sweetness from the sugar and bitters. On the other hand, I have also indulged in Old Fashioneds with a cherry garnish, appreciating the additional layer of flavor and visual appeal it brings to the cocktail.
While the traditional Old Fashioned does not call for a cherry garnish, the cocktail has evolved over time, and it is not uncommon to find variations that include a cherry. Whether or not to include a cherry in an Old Fashioned is a matter of personal taste and preference. Ultimately, the beauty of cocktails lies in their ability to be customized and tailored to suit individual palates.