The Amethyst Initiative, a project run by Choose Responsibility, is an organization that seeks to reevaluate and challenge the current minimum drinking age laws in the United States. The initiative aims to spark a debate about whether the 10% highway fund “incentive” provided to states encourages or inhibits an informed and dispassionate discussion on the topic.
The National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984 mandated that states raise the legal drinking age to 21 in order to receive federal highway funding. Since then, the majority of states have followed this law and allowed for very few exceptions where someone under 21 can legally consume alcohol. However, the Amethyst Initiative and Choose Responsibility argue that this strict age requirement may not be the most effective approach to addressing alcohol-related issues.
The Amethyst Initiative specifically calls for a reconsideration of the minimum drinking age, suggesting that the current laws may be counterproductive. By prohibiting young adults between the ages of 18 and 20 from legally consuming alcohol, the argument is that it pushes drinking underground and fosters a culture of reckless and irresponsible behavior.
Choose Responsibility, the organization behind the Amethyst Initiative, believes that lowering the drinking age to 18, while simultaneously implementing comprehensive education and alcohol management programs, could lead to a safer and more responsible drinking culture. They argue that by providing young adults with the opportunity to learn about responsible alcohol consumption in controlled environments, they will be better equipped to make responsible decisions when it comes to drinking.
The Amethyst Initiative and Choose Responsibility have gained support from various college and university presidents, who believe that the current drinking age laws create a disconnect between the legal drinking age and the reality of alcohol consumption on campuses. These presidents argue that by engaging in an open dialogue and reevaluating the current laws, universities can play a more proactive role in promoting responsible drinking habits among their students.
It is important to note that the Amethyst Initiative and Choose Responsibility do not advocate for a complete abandonment of age restrictions on alcohol consumption. Rather, they propose a shift towards a more comprehensive approach that includes education, support systems, and responsible drinking practices.
Personally, as a sommelier and brewer, I have witnessed the effects of both responsible and irresponsible drinking. I believe that education plays a crucial role in promoting responsible alcohol consumption. When individuals are taught about the different types of alcohol, their flavors, and how to consume them in moderation, they are more likely to make informed decisions and avoid excessive drinking.
Furthermore, I have seen firsthand how the current drinking age laws can contribute to a culture of binge drinking and risky behavior. By prohibiting young adults from legally consuming alcohol until the age of 21, it creates an allure of rebellion and secrecy. Instead of learning about responsible drinking habits and moderation, many young adults are forced to experiment with alcohol in unsafe environments.
However, I also understand the concerns and risks associated with lowering the drinking age. Alcohol can have detrimental effects on the developing brain, and it is important to consider the potential consequences of allowing younger individuals access to alcohol.
The Amethyst Initiative and Choose Responsibility seek to initiate a debate on the effectiveness of the current minimum drinking age laws in the United States. They propose a comprehensive approach that includes education and responsible drinking practices. While the topic is complex and requires careful consideration, it is crucial to engage in an open and informed discussion to find the most effective strategies for addressing alcohol-related issues in society.