Basil Hayden and Basil Hayden Toast are both bourbon whiskies, but they have some notable differences. Let's explore the distinctions between the two expressions.
1. Mash Bill: The primary difference lies in the mash bill, which is the combination of grains used in making the whiskey. Basil Hayden is made with a traditional bourbon mash bill consisting of corn, rye, and malted barley. On the other hand, Basil Hayden Toast features a unique mash bill that replaces the rye with brown rice. This substitution brings a different flavor profile to the whiskey.
2. Toasted Barrel Finish: Another significant difference is the use of a toasted barrel finish in Basil Hayden Toast. This means that after aging in new charred oak barrels, the whiskey is transferred to barrels that have been toasted rather than charred. This toasting process imparts distinct flavors and aromas to the whiskey, enhancing its complexity.
3. Flavor Profile: Basil Hayden is known for its smooth and approachable character. It offers notes of caramel, vanilla, spice, and a hint of rye spiciness from its traditional mash bill. On the other hand, Basil Hayden Toast brings a slightly different flavor profile due to the brown rice in its mash bill. It offers a softer, fruit-forward profile with hints of toasted oak, caramelized sugar, ripe berries, and a touch of spice.
4. Proof and Bottling Strength: Basil Hayden is typically bottled at 80 proof (40% ABV), which is a standard bottling strength for many bourbons. However, Basil Hayden Toast is bottled at a slightly higher proof of 80.8 (40.4% ABV), adding a touch more intensity to the overall experience.
5. Limited Edition Release: Basil Hayden Toast is a limited edition release, meaning it may not be available year-round or in large quantities. This exclusivity adds to its allure and makes it a sought-after expression for whiskey enthusiasts.
Personal Experience:
I have had the opportunity to taste both Basil Hayden and Basil Hayden Toast, and I must say, they each have their own unique appeal. The original Basil Hayden offers a classic bourbon experience with its smoothness and balanced flavors. It's a whiskey that can be enjoyed neat or in cocktails.
On the other hand, Basil Hayden Toast brings a delightful twist to the traditional bourbon profile. The toasted barrel finish adds layers of complexity, and the brown rice in the mash bill contributes to a softer, more fruit-forward character. I found it to be a great sipping whiskey, perfect for enjoying on its own.
Basil Hayden and Basil Hayden Toast are distinct expressions within the Basil Hayden bourbon range. While both offer their own charms, the toasted barrel finish and brown rice mash bill in Basil Hayden Toast bring a unique twist to the traditional bourbon experience. Whether you prefer the classic smoothness of Basil Hayden or the fruit-forward complexity of Basil Hayden Toast, both expressions have something to offer whiskey enthusiasts.