Which beer do you pour first in a Black and Tan?

Answered by Andrew Fritz

When creating a Black and Tan, it is crucial to pour the beers in the correct order to achieve the desired layered effect. As an expert sommelier and brewer, I can confidently share that the first you should pour in a Black and Tan is the pale .

The reason for starting with the pale ale is rooted in the concept of density. Density refers to the mass or amount of substance within a given volume. In the case of layered drinks like Black and Tan, the density of the liquids plays a vital role in their ability to stay separated.

To successfully create layers, the liquid with a lighter density needs to float on top of the liquid with a higher density. In the context of a Black and Tan, the pale ale is typically lighter in density compared to Guinness, which is a .

As a personal anecdote, I vividly remember my first attempt at making a Black and Tan. I poured the Guinness first, assuming that the darker beer would naturally sink to the bottom. However, much to my disappointment, the two beers quickly mixed together, resulting in a muddled appearance.

After some research and experimentation, I learned that the pale ale should be poured first. The lighter density of the pale ale allows it to float on top of the darker Guinness, creating a distinct separation between the two beers.

To pour a Black and Tan correctly, follow these steps:

1. Choose a sturdy pint glass or a Black and Tan spoon.
2. Hold the glass at a slight angle, around 45 degrees.
3. Slowly pour the pale ale into the glass, aiming for the center and allowing it to gently slide down the side.
4. Once the glass is about halfway full, start pouring the Guinness. Again, pour it slowly and aim for the center of the glass.
5. As you pour the Guinness, it will gradually fill up the remaining space in the glass and settle beneath the pale ale.
6. To enhance the layered effect, you can use a Black and Tan spoon. Place the spoon upside down over the glass, with the rounded side facing up. Pour the Guinness over the spoon, allowing it to flow gently onto the pale ale. The spoon helps to slow down the pouring process and prevent immediate mixing of the two beers.

Remember, the success of a Black and Tan relies on the density difference between the two beers. By pouring the pale ale first, which typically has a lighter density, you ensure that it floats on top of the Guinness, creating a visually appealing layered effect.

When making a Black and Tan, always start by pouring the pale ale first. Its lighter density allows it to float on top of the darker Guinness, resulting in a distinct separation between the two beers. Happy pouring and enjoy your perfectly layered Black and Tan!