In my experience as a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and analyze various ginger ales including Canada Dry and Seagram's. While both brands have their merits, I must say that Seagram's stands out as the better choice.
When it comes to flavor, Seagram's ginger ale has a distinct and robust taste that is both refreshing and satisfying. The ginger flavor is pronounced without being overpowering, and there is a perfect balance of sweetness and spiciness. On the other hand, Canada Dry ginger ale tends to have a lighter and milder flavor profile. While some may prefer this subtlety, I personally find it lacking when compared to the boldness of Seagram's.
In terms of carbonation, Seagram's also takes the lead. The bubbles in Seagram's ginger ale are fine and effervescent, creating a pleasant and lively mouthfeel. In contrast, I find that Canada Dry can sometimes be overly carbonated, resulting in a slightly harsher sensation on the palate. This can be particularly noticeable when drinking it straight or in cocktails.
Another aspect that sets Seagram's apart is its ingredient list. While both brands use high fructose corn syrup as a sweetener, Seagram's seems to have a slightly cleaner taste. However, it is important to note that the presence of high fructose corn syrup still leaves a sticky aftertaste that lingers, regardless of the brand. This is an inherent drawback of most store-bought ginger ales and cannot be completely avoided.
In terms of branding and packaging, both Canada Dry and Seagram's have recognizable and iconic designs. However, I find Seagram's to have a more classic and sophisticated aesthetic, which adds to the overall experience of enjoying their ginger ale.
Personal experiences have also played a role in shaping my preference for Seagram's. I have found that Seagram's ginger ale pairs exceptionally well with a variety of foods and can elevate the flavors of a meal. Its boldness and depth of flavor make it a versatile choice for both casual and formal occasions.
To summarize, while Canada Dry is a popular and widely available ginger ale, Seagram's emerges as the superior option. Its bold flavor, lively carbonation, and overall taste experience make it a standout choice among store brands. However, it is important to acknowledge that both brands still suffer from the use of high fructose corn syrup, which can leave a sticky aftertaste.