Is Proper Twelve actually good? As an expert sommelier and brewer, I can provide you with an honest and detailed analysis of this whiskey blend.
Let's start by addressing the fact that Proper Twelve is not exceptional in comparison to other whiskeys. It doesn't stand out as particularly great, but it also doesn't fall into the category of being worse than other blends. It falls somewhere in the middle, offering a decent drinking experience without being extraordinary.
One aspect to consider when evaluating Proper Twelve is its taste profile. It combines both bitter and sweet flavors, creating a balance that some may find appealing. However, this can also make it a bit rough around the edges when used in cocktails or punch, as the contrasting flavors might not always complement the other ingredients.
That being said, Proper Twelve can still be enjoyed by individuals who prefer to drink their whiskey with a mixer. The combination of bitter and sweet can work well when paired with certain mixers, allowing for a more enjoyable drinking experience. Whether it's a classic whiskey and coke or a more elaborate cocktail, Proper Twelve can hold its own when mixed.
Now, it's important to note that taste preferences are subjective, and what one person might find enjoyable, another might not. So, while I can provide you with an objective analysis, it ultimately comes down to personal preference.
In my own experiences, I have found that Proper Twelve is a suitable whiskey for casual occasions or social gatherings where mixing drinks is more common. It may not be the first choice for those seeking a complex and refined sipping whiskey, but it serves its purpose in certain settings.
To summarize, Proper Twelve is neither exceptional nor subpar compared to other whiskeys. Its combination of bitter and sweet flavors makes it better suited for mixed drinks rather than straight sipping. However, taste preferences vary greatly, and what one person may enjoy, another may not. Ultimately, the decision of whether Proper Twelve is “good” or not lies in the hands and palates of the individual drinker.