As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste a wide variety of whiskies, including ryes. Blue Run Emerald Rye is certainly an interesting addition to the rye whiskey market. It is evident that the distillers have put effort into creating a spicy and robust flavor profile that will appeal to rye enthusiasts.
Upon tasting Blue Run Emerald Rye, I found that the spiciness of the rye was definitely prominent. It had a bold and fiery character that lingered on the palate. If you enjoy the intense flavors that rye whiskey can offer, then this expression may be right up your alley. However, I must note that the spice may be overpowering for some, so it is important to consider personal taste preferences when evaluating this whiskey.
One aspect that I appreciate is that Blue Run Emerald Rye is a first run of the company's new distillate being made at Castle & Key. It is always exciting to try a product from a distillery that is just starting out, as they often bring fresh perspectives and innovative techniques to the table. This particular expression showcases the potential that Blue Run has in producing quality rye whiskies.
However, when considering the price point of Blue Run's rye line, I must admit that I expected a bit more. The price being charged for this whiskey may be a bit steep for what it delivers. While the flavor profile is certainly bold, there are other rye whiskies on the market that offer similar depth and complexity at a more reasonable price.
In my opinion, Blue Run Emerald Rye is a solid choice for rye enthusiasts who enjoy a spicy and intense flavor profile. It is a promising first release from Blue Run's new distillate, but I hope to see further refinement and complexity in their future rye offerings. Ultimately, the decision of whether this whiskey is “good” or not will depend on individual taste preferences and the value one places on the unique characteristics it brings to the table.