Which Weller tastes like Pappy?

As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the pleasure of tasting a wide variety of whiskies, including both Pappy Van Winkle and Weller. While there is much debate about which Weller expression tastes the most like Pappy, I believe that Weller 12 is the best off-the-shelf alternative.

Weller 12, also known as W.L. Weller Special Reserve, is part of the Weller line of wheated bourbons, which means that the majority of the grain used in the mash bill is wheat, rather than rye. This gives the whiskey a softer, smoother flavor profile compared to traditional bourbons that use rye as the secondary grain.

When comparing Weller 12 to Pappy Van Winkle, there are certainly similarities in terms of flavor profile. Both whiskies possess a rich and complex character with notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak. They also share a smoothness and depth that is characteristic of well-aged bourbons.

In my personal experience, I have found that Weller 12 showcases a lovely balance of flavors, with the sweetness of caramel and vanilla complemented by hints of oak and spice. The finish is long and satisfying, leaving a warm and lingering sensation on the palate.

While it is important to note that Weller 12 is not exactly the same as Pappy Van Winkle, it is a fantastic alternative for those who are unable to get their hands on a bottle of Pappy. In fact, Weller 12 has gained quite a reputation in its own right, often referred to as the “poor man's Pappy.”

One of the reasons why Weller 12 is considered a great alternative is because it is made by the same distillery that produces Pappy Van Winkle. Both brands are produced by the Buffalo Trace Distillery in Kentucky, which is known for its high-quality bourbon production. This shared heritage ensures a similar level of craftsmanship and attention to detail in the production of both whiskies.

Another reason why Weller 12 is often compared to Pappy is because it shares a similar age statement. Weller 12 is aged for 12 years, just like some expressions of Pappy Van Winkle. This extended aging period allows for greater complexity and depth of flavor to develop in the whiskey, resulting in a more refined drinking experience.

In terms of availability and affordability, Weller 12 also stands out. While Pappy Van Winkle has become notoriously difficult to find and is often priced at exorbitant levels due to its rarity, Weller 12 is relatively easier to come by and is generally more reasonably priced. This makes it a great option for those who want to experience a similar flavor profile without breaking the bank.