As an expert sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and compare wines from both the 2017 and 2018 vintages in Burgundy. While it is difficult to definitively say if one vintage is better than the other, I can certainly share my observations and experiences.
Firstly, it is important to note that both vintages have their own unique characteristics and qualities. The wines from 2017 are generally considered to be more delicate and approachable. They display vibrant fruit flavors, elegant structure, and a certain finesse that is quite appealing. These wines are already quite drinkable and enjoyable, making them a great choice for those who prefer a lighter and more nuanced style of Burgundy.
On the other hand, the wines from 2018 are richer and more concentrated. This vintage has delivered more weight and intensity, particularly in the more generic or entry-level wines. While still approachable and drinkable now, these wines have the potential to develop further complexity and depth with some additional aging. The 2018 vintage offers a bolder and more opulent expression of Burgundy, which may appeal to those who prefer a fuller-bodied and more fruit-forward style.
In terms of availability and value, the 2018 vintage has an advantage. Due to favorable growing conditions, there was a larger overall production in 2018, resulting in more widely available wines. This means that consumers have a greater chance of finding and enjoying wines from this vintage. Additionally, the increased supply has also made the wines more affordable and accessible, making them an attractive option for those looking for good value in Burgundy.
It is worth noting that personal taste plays a significant role in determining which vintage is preferred. Some wine enthusiasts may favor the delicacy and elegance of the 2017 wines, while others may appreciate the richness and concentration of the 2018 wines. Ultimately, both vintages offer their own strengths and can provide a wonderful drinking experience.
The 2017 and 2018 vintages in Burgundy each have their own distinct qualities. While the 2017 wines are more delicate and already drinkable, the 2018 wines are richer and more concentrated, with potential for further development. The 2018 vintage also offers greater availability and value, making it an attractive option for wine enthusiasts. Ultimately, the preference between the two vintages comes down to personal taste and the specific characteristics that one seeks in a Burgundy wine.