When it comes to selecting the best rum for a Mary Pickford cocktail, it's important to consider the flavor profile that will complement the fruity and tropical nature of the drink. While the original recipe likely called for a light Cuban rum like Bacardi or Havana Club, I believe that a dark rum with a drier spice finish can elevate the cocktail to new heights.
One rum that comes to mind is the Dos Maderas 5+3. This rum is a blend of rums from Barbados and Guyana, which are aged separately for five years before being shipped to Spain for an additional three years of aging in sherry casks. This extra maturation imparts a rich and complex flavor profile to the rum, making it an excellent choice for the Mary Pickford.
The Dos Maderas 5+3 has a deep amber color and a nose that is full of dried fruits, toffee, and vanilla. On the palate, it offers notes of dark chocolate, caramel, and roasted nuts, with just a hint of spice. The finish is long and dry, with a lingering warmth that adds depth to the cocktail.
When paired with the pineapple and grenadine in the Mary Pickford, the drier spice finish of the Dos Maderas 5+3 harmonizes beautifully with the sweetness of the drink. The rum's rich flavors and complexity complement the fruity character of the cocktail, creating a balanced and satisfying drinking experience.
Of course, taste is subjective, and personal preference plays a significant role in choosing the best rum for any cocktail. Some other dark rums that you may consider experimenting with include the Plantation Original Dark, Appleton Estate Reserve Blend, or El Dorado 12 Year Old. Each of these rums brings its own unique flavor profile to the table and can provide a different twist on the classic Mary Pickford.
While the original Mary Pickford may have been made with a light Cuban rum, the addition of a drier spice finish dark rum like the Dos Maderas 5+3 can enhance the flavors of the cocktail and take it to the next level. Experimenting with different rums can be a fun and exciting way to personalize your Mary Pickford and discover the perfect balance of flavors that suits your taste. Cheers!