The Perfect Manhattan: How to Make the Best Whiskey Cocktail

For many enthusiasts, the Manhattan is an iconic classic cocktail. This sophisticated blend of whiskey, sweet , and bitters has graced bar menus for generations. Whether you prefer your Manhattan on the rocks or served up in a martini glass, it's no wondr why this timeless drink continues to be a crowd favorite.

At its core, the Manhattan is a simple yet sophisticated mix of whiskey, sweet vermouth and bitters. The classic recipe calls for rye whiskey as its base spirit, but some prefer bourbon or Canadian whisky instead. The vermouth provdes both sweetness and complexity to the drink while the bitters add balance and depth of flavor. To round out the cocktail's flavor profile, some recipes call for a few drops of orange or Angostura bitters as well.

When selecting your ingredients for this classic cocktail, quality matters. Choose a top-shelf whiskey that you enjoy sipping neat to ensure that your finished product is smooth and balanced. As far as vermouth goes, look for one with notes of floral aromatics and subtle sweetness that won't overpower the othr ingredients in your Manhattan.

Once you have all your ingredients selected, it's time to mix up your perfect Manhattan! Start by combining 2 ounces of rye whiskey (or bourbon/Canadian whisky) with 1 ounce of sweet vermouth in a shaker filled with ice cubes. Add two dashes of Angostura bitters and stir until well-combined. Strain the mixture into an ice-filled glass (rocks glass or martini glass) then garnish with an orange peel or maraschino cherry beore serving.

The Manhattan is tuly one of the most beloved cocktails out there – so if you haven't tried one yet, now is definitely the time! Be sure to use high-quality ingredients when making yours so that you can fully appreciate this timeless classic in all its glory!

What is the Best Whiskey to Use for a Manhattan?

When it comes to crafting the perfect Manhattan, the whiskey you choose is an essential component. The best whiskey to use in a Manhattan cocktail is a smooth, flavorful rye or bourbon. Rye whiskey adds a sharp, spicy flavor to the drink, while bourbon proides hints of caramel and vanilla. Popular whiskeys for Manhattans include Teeling Single Whiskey, Jack Daniel's Old No. 7 Whiskey, The Balvenie DoubleWood Whisky, Sagamore Spirit Rye Double Oak Rye Whisky, Michter's US-1 Kentucky Straight Rye, Knob Creek 9-Year-Old Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey, and Lost Republic Straight Rye Whiskey. Ultimately, which whiskey you choose for your Manhattan depends on your own personal preferences and tastes.

best whiskey manhattan

The Benefits of Using Rye in a Manhattan

Rye whiskey is widely regarded as the best base for a Manhattan, but some drinkers may prefer to use other options such as bourbon or Canadian whisky. Rye has a spicier, more robust flavor profile compared to other whiskies, and it stands up very well to the sweet vermouth in a Manhattan. For those looking for an authentic Manhattan experience, rye is definitely the way to go.

Top 5 Whiskeys

The top 5 whiskeys in the world are:
1. Midleton Dair Ghaelach Kylebeg Wood Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey – this whiskey is aged for 15 to 22 years in hand-selected oak barrels, creating a wonderfully complex flavor full of spicy notes, nutty aromas, and hints of sweet honey.
2. Larceny Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey – this whiskey is a blend of six-year-old bourbons finished with a higher proof than traditional Larceny and bottled directly from the barrel. It has a rich, oaky flavor with notes of vanilla and toffee.
3. Jameson Bow Street 18 YO Cask Strength Irish Blended Whiskey – this whiskey is distilled three times using only the finest ingredients and aged in seasoned oak barrels. It has an intense flavor profile with notes of butterscotch, dried fruit, and spices.
4. Uncle Nearest Master Blend Edition Premium Tennessee Whiskey – this whiskey is made from a carefully selected blend of whiskeys aged for 8-14 years in white oak barrels. It has an incredibly smooth finish with notes of caramel, vanilla, and light fruit flavors.
5. The Yamazaki Cask 2018 Edition Whisky – produced at Japan's oldest whisky distillery, this single malt whisky is matured for at least 18 years in sherry casks beore bottling to create a sweet yet complex flavor profile with hints of dried fruit and spices.

What Type of Alcohol is Used to Make a Manhattan?

A Manhattan is traditionally made with American Rye whiskey, as it has a spicier, drier flavor than Bourbon. This spicy flavor profile provides the perfect balance of sweet vermouth and bitters in this classic cocktail. Bourbon can be substituted for Rye in a Manhattan if desired, however, the drink will have a sweeter taste.

Using Whiskey to Make a Manhattan Cocktail

Yes, whiskey is the traditional spirit used to make a Manhattan. It is usually made with either rye whiskey or bourbon, depending on your preference. Canadian whisky has also been used as an alternative. When making a Manhattan, it's important to use good quality whiskey, sweet vermouth and bitters in order to get the best results. The ratio of whiskey to vermouth should be 2:1, so for a single serve you'd use 2 ounces of whiskey and 1 ounce of vermouth. You can then add 2-3 dashes of Angostura or orange bitters to taste. Enjoy!

What Makes a Good Manhattan Cocktail?

A good Manhattan should have a balanced combination of sweetness and bitterness. The whiskey's flavor should be prominent, with the sweet vermouth providng a smooth, slightly sweet undertone. The key to a great Manhattan is the balance between the bitters and sweet vermouth – you don't want either one to overpower the other. The result should be an aromatic and full-bodied cocktail with herbal undertones from the bitters. Finally, some additional complexity can be added by using an aged whiskey or adding a dash of orange . Enjoy!

Comparing the Taste of Old Fashioned and Manhattan Cocktails

The answer to whch tastes better, the Old Fashioned or Manhattan, is subjective and ultimately up to personal preference. The Old Fashioned contains sugar and bitters, making it a sweeter drink than the Manhattan. The Manhattan contains equal parts sweet vermouth and whiskey, with a hint of bitters. The complexity of the Manhattan's flavor profile is attributed to the variety of botanicals added to the vermouth, while the Old Fashioned has a more straightforward flavor due to its fewer ingredients. Depending on your preferences, either could be considered a better tasting drink.

Does the Manhattan Cocktail Taste Like Whiskey?

No, a Manhattan does not taste like whiskey. While whiskey is the main ingredient, it is combined with sweet vermouth and a few dashes of bitters to create a sophisticated cocktail with complex flavors. The whiskey contributes a strong base flavor, but the vermouth adds notes of dark red fruit, subtle herbal hints and sometimes even hints of vanilla or cola-like flavors. The bitters help to balance out the sweetness of the vermouth, creating an overall mellow sweetness that is unique to Manhattans.

best whiskey manhattan

The Best-Tasting Whiskey: A Review

The nicest tasting whiskey really coes down to personal preference, but some of the most highly rated whiskeys are considered to be Four Roses Single Barrel, Pikesville Straight Rye, Henry Mckenna Single Barrel, The Balvenie DoubleWood, West Cork 8-Year Single Malt, and Lot No. 40 Whisky. Four Roses Single Barrel is a smooth and mellow bourbon with hints of sweet fruit and spices. Pikesville Straight Rye is a full-bodied rye whiskey that has notes of rich spices and dark fruits. Henry Mckenna Single Barrel is an older bourbon that is known for its deep caramel flavors and robust finish. The Balvenie DoubleWood is a Scotch whisky with subtle notes of honey, nuts and spice. West Cork 8-Year Single Malt Irish Whiskey has a creamy texture with sweet citrus flavors and hints of vanilla. Lastly, Lot No. 40 Whisky is a Canadian whiskey with aromas of fresh apples and apricots followed by lightly spiced notes on the palate. Ultimately the best tasting whiskey depends on your individual taste buds so make sure to try out different varieties until you find the one that works best for you!

The Best Whiskeys for a Smooth Taste

The smoothest whiskey is one that has a high ABV ( by volume) and is aged for at leat 10 years. Some of the top rated whiskeys include Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon, Knob Creek 12 Year Bourbon, Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon, Old Elk Straight Bourbon, Heaven's Door Double Barrel, Evan Williams Bottled In Bond Bourbon and Five Brothers Bourbon.

Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon is a smooth and mellow whiskey with notes of oak, vanilla, toffee and caramel. It has an ABV of 45% and is aged in charred American Oak barrels for 10 years.

Knob Creek 12 Year Bourbon has an aroma of sweet vanilla with light floral notes. Its taste is sweet and smoky with hints of caramel and oak. This bourbon has an ABV of 50% and is aged for 12 years in charred American Oak barrels.

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon has a smooth flavor profile with notes of dried fruit, honey, vanilla and oak. It boasts an ABV of 47% and is aged for at least 8 years in new charred American Oak barrels.

Old Elk Straight Bourbon is a smooth whiskey with hints of spice, toasted wood and brown sugar on the palate. It has an ABV of 40% and it's aged for 4-6 years in new charred American Oak barrels before beig bottled.

Heaven's Door Double Barrel Whiskey offers a smooth flavor profile with hints of caramelized oak and spice on the nose followd by flavors of butterscotch, honeycomb and roasted nuts on the palate. This whiskey has an ABV of 46% and it's aged first in new charred American Oak barrels before being finished in French Oak staves for 2 months.

Evan Williams Bottled In Bond Bourbon has a robust flavor profile consisting of notes of oak, caramelized sugar, black pepper, cinnamon spice, toasted nuts and ripe fruit on the palate. Its ABV is 50%, making it one of the strongest whiskeys out there! It's also aged for at least 4 years in new charred American Oak barrels before bing bottled according to federal regulations governing bonded whiskeys.

Lastly we have Five Brothers Bourbon which offers a smooth flavor profile with notes of baking spices like cinnamon & nutmeg combined with hints of caramel & honey on the nose followed by flavors like tobacco & leather on the palate. This bourbon has an ABV 40% and it's aged for 6-8 years in heavily-charred American Oak barrels before being bottled according to federal regulations governing bonded whiskies..

What Is The Top-Rated Whisky?

The Glenmorangie Signet is widely regarded as the best whisky in the world. The whisky is made with a unique blend of Glenmorangie's rarest whiskies, matured in casks that are specially selected for their individual characteristics. The whisky is also made using high roast chocolate malt barley, which adds a rich, intense flavour and complexity to the final product. The combination of these factors creates an unparalleled depth and complexity of flavour that makes Glenmorangie Signet a truly world-class spirit.

The Origin of the Name Manhattan

The Manhattan cocktail is believed to originate from the early 1880s. It was first served at a party thrown by Lady Randolph Churchill, the mother of Winston Churchill, at the Manhattan Club in New York. This is where the drink got its name: due to being served at the Manhattan Club, it has been known as the Manhattan ever since.

The exact recipe for the original Manhattan is unknown but it is thought to have been made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth and Angostura bitters, with a maraschino cherry garnish. Nowadays there are many variations on this classic cocktail, such as substituting bourbon for rye whiskey or adding other ingredients such as orange bitters or grenadine syrup.

No matter what ingredients are used to make it, one thing remains constant – the name “Manhattan” will always be associated with this classic cocktail.

The Sweetness of a Manhattan Cocktail

A Manhattan is a classic cocktail made with whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters. The combination of spirit and vermouth makes it a “perfectly balanced” cocktail, meaning it has both sweet and dry elements. It can be served either way depending on personal preference, but the traditional ratio for a Manhattan is 2 parts whiskey to 1 part sweet vermouth. This gves the cocktail a slight sweetness that is offset by the dryness of the whiskey. For an even drier version, you can use less sweet vermouth or add extra dry vermouth to the mix. A lemon twist is often used as a garnish for both versions of this classic cocktail.


The Manhattan is a classic whiskey cocktail that is enjoyed the world over. It is a simple yet sophisticated drink made with just three ingredients – whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters. It is an easy-to-make drink that can be served both neat or on the rocks and can be enjoyed by whiskey lovers of all levels. Its distinct flavor profile makes it a great choice for sipping straight or as an accompaniment to a meal. The Manhattan also pairs well with many differet types of food, making it a versatile cocktail for any occasion. With its timeless appeal, the Manhattan is sure to remain one of the most beloved whiskey cocktails for many years to come.

Photo of author

Thomas Ashford

Thomas Ashford is a highly educated brewer with years of experience in the industry. He has a Bachelor Degree in Chemistry and a Master Degree in Brewing Science. He is also BJCP Certified Beer Judge. Tom has worked hard to become one of the most experienced brewers in the industry. He has experience monitoring brewhouse and cellaring operations, coordinating brewhouse projects, and optimizing brewery operations for maximum efficiency. He is also familiar mixology and an experienced sommelier. Tom is an expert organizer of beer festivals, wine tastings, and brewery tours.