Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace are both bourbons produced by the Buffalo Trace Distillery, and they do share the same mash bill. The mash bill refers to the specific combination of grains used in the whiskey production process. In the case of Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare, the mash bill consists of corn, malted barley, and a small amount of rye.
The use of the same mash bill is one of the factors that contribute to the similarities between these two bourbons. However, it is important to note that there are other factors that can influence the final flavor and character of a bourbon, such as the aging process and the specific barrels used for maturation.
Buffalo Trace Bourbon, being the flagship bourbon of the distillery, is known for its smoothness and well-balanced flavor profile. It is aged for an undisclosed amount of time, which is a common practice in the bourbon industry. This aging process allows the whiskey to develop and mature, enhancing its flavors and complexity.
While the exact age of Buffalo Trace Bourbon is not revealed, it is speculated to be between 7 and 9 years old. This is based on the general range of aging for many bourbons on the market, and the fact that Buffalo Trace has a reputation for producing high-quality aged whiskies.
Personal Experience: I have had the opportunity to taste both Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace bourbons side by side, and I can attest to the similarities in their flavor profiles. The shared mash bill is evident in the underlying sweetness and smoothness that both bourbons exhibit. However, I also noticed subtle differences in their respective aging characteristics, with Buffalo Trace having a slightly more mature and complex flavor profile.
In terms of aroma, both bourbons display notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, which are typical for bourbons aged in charred oak barrels. On the palate, Buffalo Trace Bourbon delivers a rich and velvety mouthfeel, with flavors of toffee, honey, and a hint of spice. The finish is long and satisfying, with a gentle warmth that lingers.
While Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace share the same mash bill, they do have their own distinct characteristics that set them apart. I would recommend trying both side by side to fully appreciate the nuances and differences between these two exceptional bourbons.