As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and evaluate a wide range of spirits and beverages. When it comes to bourbon, Maker's Mark is a brand that has always stood out to me. While some may consider it to be a mid-shelf bourbon, I personally believe that it deserves a top shelf rating, especially when it comes to their cask strength expression.
Maker's Mark is known for its distinctive wheated bourbon, which sets it apart from other bourbons that typically use rye as the secondary grain. This gives Maker's Mark a softer and smoother flavor profile, with a focus on sweetness and a lack of spiciness. The regular version of Maker's Mark is already a solid choice, and I would give it a mid-shelf rating.
However, when it comes to the cask strength version of Maker's Mark, I believe it truly shines and deserves a top shelf rating. The cask strength expression is bottled at a higher proof, typically around 110-115 proof, compared to the regular version which is bottled at 90 proof. This higher proof allows the flavors to be more concentrated and intensified, resulting in a more complex and robust bourbon.
One of the standout qualities of Maker's Mark cask strength is its balance. Despite the higher proof, it remains smooth and approachable, without being overpowering or harsh. The flavors are well-rounded and well-integrated, with notes of caramel, vanilla, oak, and a hint of spice. The finish is long and satisfying, leaving a warm and lingering sensation.
What makes Maker's Mark cask strength even more impressive is its accessibility. While other wheated bourbons like Pappy Van Winkle and W.L. Weller are highly sought after and difficult to find, Maker's Mark cask strength is more widely available. This makes it a great option for bourbon enthusiasts who want to enjoy a top shelf wheated bourbon on a regular basis, without the hassle of searching for rare and elusive bottles.
Personally, I have enjoyed many bottles of Maker's Mark cask strength over the years and have always been impressed with its quality and consistency. It has become a go-to choice for me when I want to indulge in a premium wheated bourbon without breaking the bank or going on a wild goose chase to find rare bottles.
While some may consider Maker's Mark to be a mid-shelf bourbon, I believe that their cask strength expression deserves a top shelf rating. Its exceptional balance, complex flavors, and accessibility make it one of the best widely available wheated bourbons on the market. So, if you're looking to elevate your bourbon experience, I highly recommend giving Maker's Mark cask strength a try. Cheers!