Is moonshine closer to vodka or whiskey?

Answered by Bill Hernandez

Moonshine is a unique spirit that often falls somewhere in between and in terms of flavor profile. While it is commonly associated with the illicit production of , moonshine has gained popularity in recent years as a legal and regulated spirit. However, its roots lie in the clandestine distilling practices of the past, where obtaining and maintaining oak for aging was a significant challenge.

Historically, moonshine was produced in small, homemade stills, often hidden away in remote locations to avoid detection. These makeshift stills were not equipped for aging , and as a result, moonshine was typically consumed shortly after distillation. Unlike whiskey, which is aged in oak barrels to develop complex flavors and aromas, moonshine was rarely given the opportunity to mature.

The absence of aging in oak barrels is a key factor in moonshine's flavor profile. Oak barrels are known to impart distinct characteristics to spirits, such as vanilla, caramel, and spice notes. Without this maturation process, moonshine lacks the depth and complexity typically associated with whiskeys aged in oak.

Instead, moonshine often exhibits a cleaner, more neutral taste, similar to vodka. Vodka is known for its smooth, almost flavorless profile, allowing it to be mixed seamlessly into . Moonshine, due to its lack of aging and minimal contact with oak, can also have a similar neutrality, making it a versatile base for mixed drinks.

However, it is important to note that moonshine's flavor can vary significantly depending on the production methods and ingredients used. Since there were no legal criteria for moonshine production in the past, each batch could have its own unique flavor profile. Some moonshines may have had hints of corn or other grains used in the mash, while others might have had a more pronounced fruity or floral character.

In my personal experience as a sommelier and brewer, I have tasted a range of moonshines that showcase this diversity in flavor. Some moonshines I've tried had a crisp, clean taste reminiscent of a well-made vodka, while others had a slightly sweet, corn-forward profile akin to a young, unaged whiskey. I've also encountered moonshines that had unexpected flavors such as apple or even hints of smoke, showcasing the creativity and experimentation that can be found in the production of this spirit.

Moonshine's flavor is more akin to vodka than a dark-colored whiskey due to its lack of aging in oak barrels. The absence of oak maturation allows moonshine to have a cleaner, more neutral taste, similar to vodka. However, it is important to note that moonshine's flavor can vary greatly depending on the production methods used, resulting in a diverse range of profiles that can showcase the creativity and craftsmanship of the distiller.