In my opinion, Sailor Jerry's is a good rum. As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to try numerous spiced rums, and while Sailor Jerry's may not be the absolute best in its category, it is certainly a solid choice.
One of the reasons why I believe Sailor Jerry's is a good rum is its versatility in cocktails. It has a strong and bold flavor profile that can hold its own when mixed with other ingredients. Whether you're making a classic rum and coke, a mai tai, or a spiced rum punch, Sailor Jerry's will add a nice kick and depth to your drink.
Another factor that makes Sailor Jerry's a good option is its accessibility. It is widely available in liquor stores, making it easy to find and purchase. This can be particularly convenient if you're hosting a gathering or need to quickly restock your home bar.
That being said, it is important to note that the spiced rum category is highly subjective, and taste preferences can vary greatly from person to person. While I personally enjoy Sailor Jerry's, others may have different opinions.
If you're looking to explore other options within the spiced rum category, I would recommend trying El Dorado Spiced or Crusoe. El Dorado Spiced offers a more complex and refined flavor profile with hints of caramel and vanilla, while Crusoe provides a smoother and less sweet experience. Both of these rums are regarded highly within the spiced rum community and may offer a different experience compared to Sailor Jerry's.
Alternatively, if you're feeling adventurous, you could consider making your own spiced rum. This allows you to customize the flavors and create a truly unique product. There are plenty of recipes and guides available online to help you get started. It can be a fun and rewarding experience to experiment with different spices and flavors to create a rum that suits your personal taste preferences.
Sailor Jerry's is a good rum, particularly if you're looking for a reliable option that can be easily found at most liquor stores. However, if you're open to exploring other options or want to have a more personalized experience, there are certainly other spiced rums worth considering or even making your own.