When it comes to the question of whether VS (Very Special) cognac is better than VSOP (Very Superior Old Pale) cognac, it ultimately boils down to personal preference. As a sommelier and brewer with a passion for spirits, I can shed some light on the topic.
Firstly, it's important to understand the aging process of cognac. Cognac is made from grapes, specifically Ugni Blanc, that are fermented and then distilled twice. The resulting spirit is aged in oak barrels, which imparts flavors and aromas to the cognac over time.
VS cognac, also known as three-star or * cognac, is aged for a minimum of two years. It is the youngest and least expensive category of cognac. VS cognacs tend to have a fresher, livelier aroma with prominent notes of fruit. They are often described as being more vibrant and youthful in character.
On the other hand, VSOP cognac, also known as five-star or cognac, is aged for a minimum of four years. The additional aging allows the cognac to develop more complexity and depth. VSOP cognacs are generally smoother on the palate, with a richer flavor profile and more pronounced notes of oak and spices. The extended aging also contributes to a mellower and more refined drinking experience.
It's worth noting that age alone does not determine the quality or superiority of a cognac. While older cognacs have had more time to develop and evolve in the barrel, there are many other factors that contribute to the overall quality, such as the quality of the grapes, the skill of the distiller, and the blending techniques used.
Personal taste plays a significant role in determining which category of cognac is better. Some people prefer the vibrant and fruity character of a VS cognac, enjoying its youthful and energetic nature. Others may gravitate towards the smoother and more complex profile of a VSOP cognac, appreciating its depth and sophistication.
To truly determine which category of cognac is better for you, I would recommend exploring both VS and VSOP expressions from reputable producers. Taste them side by side, paying attention to the aromas, flavors, and overall drinking experience. Consider the occasion, your mood, and the flavors you enjoy.
In my personal experiences, I have found that there are exceptional cognacs in both the VS and VSOP categories. I have enjoyed vibrant and fruity VS cognacs that are perfect for sipping on warm summer evenings, as well as velvety and complex VSOP cognacs that are ideal for colder winter nights by the fireplace. It all comes down to personal preference and the specific characteristics you appreciate in a cognac.
Whether VS cognac is better than VSOP cognac is subjective and depends on individual taste. VS cognacs tend to be fresher and fruitier, while VSOP cognacs are smoother and more complex. Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to personal preference and the specific qualities you seek in a cognac. So, explore and enjoy the wide range of cognacs available, and let your own palate be the judge.