As an expert sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste a wide variety of whiskeys, including both single barrel and small batch options. However, I must emphasize that determining which is better is highly subjective and dependent on individual preferences.
Let's start by discussing single barrel whiskeys. These are made from a single barrel and are not blended with any other barrels. This means that each bottle of single barrel bourbon, for example, is unique in its flavor profile. The taste of a single barrel whiskey can be quite distinct, offering a more concentrated and intense flavor experience. This can be appealing to those who enjoy bold and robust flavors.
One of the advantages of single barrel whiskeys is the opportunity to experience the nuances and characteristics of a specific barrel. Each barrel may have its own aging process, leading to variations in flavor profiles. Some barrels may have a more pronounced oak influence, while others may exhibit notes of vanilla, caramel, or even fruity undertones. This uniqueness can be highly sought after by whiskey enthusiasts who appreciate the individuality of each bottle.
On the other hand, small batch whiskeys are made by blending a select number of barrels. The exact definition of small batch can vary among distilleries, but generally, it refers to a limited number of barrels being used for the blend. This blending process allows for a balance and harmonization of flavors, as different barrels can contribute their own characteristics to the final product.
Small batch whiskeys often aim to create a more well-rounded and complex flavor profile. The blending process can smooth out any inconsistencies or imperfections that may be present in a single barrel whiskey. The result is often a whiskey with a broader range of flavors, where multiple elements come together to create a cohesive and enjoyable drinking experience.
In my personal experience, I have found that small batch whiskeys can offer a more approachable and versatile drinking experience. The blending process allows for a balance of flavors, where the individual characteristics of each barrel are melded together to create a cohesive whole. This can be particularly appealing to those who appreciate a well-rounded and harmonious taste.
That being said, there are certainly occasions where a single barrel whiskey shines. For those who enjoy the uniqueness and intensity of flavors, a single barrel option can be a captivating choice. It allows for a deeper exploration of the complexities that can arise from the aging process and the individual characteristics of a specific barrel.
Ultimately, whether single barrel or small batch whiskeys are better comes down to personal preference. Some individuals may prefer the strong and distinct flavors offered by single barrel whiskeys, while others may appreciate the blending and balance found in small batch options. The important thing is to explore and experiment with different types of whiskeys to discover what suits your own palate and preferences.