When it comes to making an Old Fashioned, the choice of whiskey is crucial. You want a whiskey that can stand up to the other ingredients in the cocktail and bring its own unique flavors to the mix. While there are many great options out there, I have two personal favorites that I believe make for exceptional Old Fashioneds: Bare Knuckle Straight Wheat Whiskey and Old Hamer Straight Rye.
Bare Knuckle Straight Wheat Whiskey is a fantastic choice for an Old Fashioned because of its smoothness and depth of flavor. Made from a high percentage of wheat, this whiskey has a soft and velvety mouthfeel that works beautifully in a cocktail. It has notes of vanilla, caramel, and baking spices that complement the sweetness of the sugar and the complexity of the bitters in an Old Fashioned. The wheat also adds a subtle nuttiness that adds another layer of flavor to the drink. I find that the Bare Knuckle Straight Wheat Whiskey brings a lovely balance to the cocktail, making it incredibly enjoyable to sip on.
Old Hamer Straight Rye, on the other hand, is a whiskey that packs a punch. Rye whiskey is known for its bold and spicy character, and that's exactly what you get with Old Hamer. This rye whiskey has a robust flavor profile with notes of black pepper, cinnamon, and cloves. When used in an Old Fashioned, it adds a delightful kick and complexity to the cocktail. The spiciness of the rye plays off the sweetness of the sugar and the herbal notes of the bitters, creating a well-rounded and satisfying drink. If you're a fan of strong and flavorful cocktails, then Old Hamer Straight Rye is the whiskey for you.
Now, I understand that taste is subjective, and what may be the best whiskey for an Old Fashioned for me may not be the same for someone else. That's the beauty of cocktails – they can be tailored to suit individual preferences. However, based on my own experiences and the feedback I've received from others, I believe that both Bare Knuckle Straight Wheat Whiskey and Old Hamer Straight Rye are excellent choices for making a delicious Old Fashioned.
Ultimately, the best whiskey to make an Old Fashioned with is the one that you enjoy the most. Don't be afraid to experiment and try different whiskeys to find the one that suits your palate. Whether you prefer a smooth and mellow wheat whiskey or a bold and spicy rye, the most important thing is to savor the process of making and drinking your Old Fashioned. Cheers!