As an expert sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and compare various whiskies, including the Calumet 15 and 16 year expressions. These two whiskies are both bourbon blends and are known for their smooth and complex flavors. However, there are subtle differences between the two that set them apart.
Starting with Calumet 15, I was immediately greeted with a delightful combination of vanilla, tobacco, and oak on the nose. The aroma was rich and inviting, with a hint of char adding depth to the overall profile. Upon taking a sip, I noticed a medium viscosity, which coated my palate nicely. The dominant flavors were vanilla and oak, accompanied by a light dusting of cinnamon. This added a touch of warmth and spice to the whisky, balancing out the sweetness. the Calumet 15 had a fruity and sweet character, with the tobacco and char notes adding complexity.
Moving on to Calumet 16, I found that it had a similar base profile to the 15 year, but with some notable differences. The tobacco and char notes seemed to be more pronounced in the 16, giving it a bolder and slightly smokier character. The vanilla and oak flavors were still present, but seemed to take more of a backseat to the tobacco and char. Additionally, there was a stronger presence of baking spice, which added a pleasant warmth to each sip. Compared to the 15 year, the 16 year had a slightly less fruity and sweet profile, but made up for it with its robust and smoky undertones.
In terms of overall quality, both the Calumet 15 and 16 year expressions are exceptional whiskies. They showcase the craftsmanship and attention to detail that goes into producing a premium bourbon blend. However, the nuances in flavor between the two make them distinct choices for different preferences. If you enjoy a slightly sweeter and fruit-forward bourbon with hints of tobacco and char, the Calumet 15 year may be more to your liking. On the other hand, if you prefer a bolder and smokier bourbon with a stronger emphasis on tobacco and char, the Calumet 16 year would be a great option.
It's important to note that taste preferences can vary greatly from person to person, so I always encourage individuals to try both expressions for themselves and decide which one resonates with their palate. Personal experiences and preferences play a significant role in the enjoyment and appreciation of whiskey, and what may be appealing to one person may not be the same for another.
The main differences between Calumet 15 and 16 year lie in the prominence of tobacco and char notes, as well as the overall sweetness and fruitiness of the whiskies. While the 15 year offers a more balanced and fruity profile with hints of tobacco and char, the 16 year leans towards a bolder and smokier character with a stronger emphasis on tobacco and char. Both expressions are excellent choices for bourbon enthusiasts, and the decision ultimately comes down to personal preference and taste.