When it comes to comparing Foursquare and Real McCoy rums, the main difference lies in their finishing techniques and the barrels used. Both rums are crafted with utmost care and attention to detail, resulting in exceptional quality spirits that are highly regarded in the rum world.
Foursquare rum, hailing from Barbados, is known for its versatility and innovative approach to rum production. One of the standout characteristics of Foursquare is its willingness to experiment with different cask finishes. While they do produce rums aged solely in bourbon barrels, they also explore the possibilities of other types of barrels. For example, Foursquare has released rums finished in Zinfandel casks, which impart unique flavors and nuances to the final product. This creativity allows Foursquare to offer a diverse range of expressions, each with its own distinct profile and character.
On the other hand, Real McCoy rums, also originating from Barbados, have a more traditional approach to aging and finishing. Real McCoy rums are exclusively aged in bourbon barrels, which are known for their rich and smooth flavor profiles. This commitment to using bourbon barrels gives Real McCoy rums a consistent and familiar taste, with hints of vanilla, caramel, and oak. By focusing on this specific finishing method, Real McCoy aims to showcase the true essence of Barbadian rum, capturing the authentic flavors of the Caribbean.
Having had the opportunity to taste both Foursquare and Real McCoy rums, I can attest to the distinct differences between the two. While Foursquare's experimentation with different cask finishes provides a sense of excitement and discovery, Real McCoy's dedication to bourbon barrel aging delivers a more traditional and comforting experience. Both approaches have their merits, appealing to different palates and preferences.
In terms of personal preference, I find that Foursquare's range of expressions offers a level of complexity and variety that keeps me coming back for more. Exploring their different cask finishes has allowed me to discover new flavor profiles and expand my understanding of what rum can be. However, there are moments when I crave the familiar and comforting taste of Real McCoy, with its smooth and well-rounded bourbon barrel influence.
To summarize, the main difference between Foursquare and Real McCoy rums lies in their finishing techniques and barrel choices. Foursquare's willingness to experiment with various cask finishes allows for a diverse range of expressions, while Real McCoy's commitment to bourbon barrel aging delivers a consistent and traditional flavor profile. Both rums are exceptional in their own right, catering to different preferences and offering unique experiences for rum enthusiasts.