A brandy Old Fashioned and a brandy Manhattan are both classic cocktails that have stood the test of time. While they both contain brandy as the base spirit, there are distinct differences in their ingredients and preparation that give each cocktail its own unique character.
1. Sweetener:
The sweetener used in a brandy Old Fashioned is typically a sugar cube that is muddled with a splash of water to dissolve it. This method adds a subtle sweetness and texture to the drink. On the other hand, a brandy Manhattan is sweetened with sweet vermouth, which imparts a richer and more complex sweetness to the cocktail.
2. Bittering Agent:
Both cocktails usually incorporate a bittering agent, but the type used differs. In a brandy Old Fashioned, this is typically accomplished by adding a few dashes of Angostura bitters, which lends a spicy and aromatic quality to the drink. In contrast, a brandy Manhattan traditionally calls for the use of aromatic or orange bitters, which add a different flavor profile and enhance the sweetness of the vermouth.
3. Additional Ingredients:
A brandy Old Fashioned is often garnished with an orange twist and a cherry, which provide citrusy and fruity notes to complement the brandy. Some variations may also include a splash of soda water to lighten the drink. On the other hand, a brandy Manhattan is typically garnished with a cherry, which adds a touch of sweetness and visually complements the reddish hue of the sweet vermouth.
4. Glassware:
The choice of glassware also differs between the two cocktails. A brandy Old Fashioned is traditionally served in a rocks glass or an Old Fashioned glass, which allows for muddling and sipping the cocktail. In contrast, a brandy Manhattan is typically served in a martini glass or a coupe glass, which showcases the elegant and sophisticated nature of the cocktail.
5. Flavor Profile:
Due to the differences in sweeteners and bittering agents, a brandy Old Fashioned tends to have a balanced and slightly sweeter taste profile. The sugar cube and muddled orange twist contribute to a subtle citrusy sweetness that complements the brandy. On the other hand, a brandy Manhattan has a bolder and more complex flavor profile, with the sweet vermouth providing a richer sweetness and the aromatic or orange bitters adding depth and complexity.
Personal Note:
As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the pleasure of exploring and experimenting with various classic cocktails, including the brandy Old Fashioned and brandy Manhattan. Each cocktail has its own charm and appeal, and it ultimately comes down to personal preference. I have found that the brandy Old Fashioned is a comforting and approachable cocktail, perfect for sipping and savoring on a cozy evening. On the other hand, the brandy Manhattan is a sophisticated and elegant cocktail that is best enjoyed in a more formal setting or as a pre-dinner aperitif. Both cocktails showcase the versatility of brandy and the art of mixology, making them a timeless choice for cocktail enthusiasts.
The key differences between a brandy Old Fashioned and a brandy Manhattan lie in their sweeteners, bittering agents, additional ingredients, glassware, and flavor profiles. While both cocktails feature brandy as the base spirit, they offer distinct experiences that cater to different preferences and occasions.