When it comes to choosing the perfect whiskey for a Manhattan cocktail, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. However, I can offer some insights and recommendations based on my experience as a sommelier and brewer.
Firstly, let's explore the two main contenders: American Rye and Bourbon. American Rye whiskey is known for its spicy and robust flavor profile, which can add a unique depth to a Manhattan. On the other hand, Bourbon is often associated with a sweeter and smoother taste due to its higher corn content. Some people may find this sweetness to be overpowering in a Manhattan, while others enjoy the added complexity it brings.
If you prefer a drier and spicier Manhattan, I would recommend opting for an American Rye whiskey. Rye has a long history in cocktail-making and is the traditional choice for a classic Manhattan. It provides a bold and assertive flavor that harmonizes well with the other ingredients. Rye whiskeys such as Rittenhouse Rye or Sazerac Rye are excellent options that can elevate your Manhattan to new heights.
On the other hand, if you enjoy a slightly sweeter and smoother Manhattan, a Bourbon whiskey might be more to your liking. However, it's important to note that not all Bourbons are created equal. Some Bourbons have a higher rye content, which can provide a better flavor balance in a Manhattan. A good example is New Riff's Kentucky Straight Bourbon, which has a higher rye content and offers a delightful combination of sweetness and spice.
Of course, these are just a few recommendations, and there are numerous other options available in the market. Exploring different brands and expressions can be a fun and rewarding journey. I encourage you to visit local whiskey tastings or speak with knowledgeable staff at your favorite liquor store to discover new and interesting choices.
Ultimately, the best whiskey for a Manhattan is the one that suits your personal taste preferences. Experimentation and finding the perfect balance of flavors is part of the enjoyment of crafting cocktails. So, whether you choose a spicy American Rye or a sweeter Bourbon, savor the process and enjoy the journey of discovering your ideal Manhattan. Cheers!