When it comes to deciding whether single barrel or double barrel whiskey is better, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. However, there are a few factors to consider that may help inform your decision.
Flavor is a crucial aspect to consider when evaluating the quality of a whiskey. The barrel plays a significant role in imparting flavor to the spirit, with around 60% of a bourbon's flavor coming from the barrel itself. With double barrel aging, the whiskey gets the opportunity to interact with two different barrels, allowing for a more complex and layered flavor profile. The first barrel imparts its unique characteristics to the whiskey, and the second barrel further refines and enhances those flavors. This can result in a more flavorful and nuanced bourbon.
Double barreling also has the potential to make the bourbon smoother and more sophisticated. As the whiskey spends more time in contact with the wood, it has the opportunity to mellow and undergo additional maturation. This can help to round out any harsh edges and create a smoother drinking experience. The second barrel can contribute to the refinement of the whiskey, adding depth and complexity to the final product.
I have personally experienced the impact of double barrel aging on whiskey. During a visit to a distillery, I had the opportunity to taste both single barrel and double barrel versions of their bourbon. The double barrel whiskey had a richer and more pronounced flavor profile compared to the single barrel expression. It had a pleasant smoothness and a lingering finish that made it stand out. While the single barrel whiskey was enjoyable, the double barrel version offered a more robust and satisfying drinking experience.
It is important to note that while double barreling can enhance the flavor and smoothness of a bourbon, it may not always be the preferred choice. Some whiskey enthusiasts appreciate the purity and unique characteristics of a single barrel expression. Each barrel has its own distinct flavor profile, and single barrel whiskey allows these individual characteristics to shine through without any additional influence. This can be particularly appealing to those who enjoy the complexity and variation that comes with single barrel releases.
Whether single barrel or double barrel whiskey is better is subjective and depends on personal preference. Double barreling can result in a more flavorful, refined, and smoother bourbon, while single barrel expressions showcase the unique characteristics of each barrel. Exploring both options can lead to a deeper appreciation and understanding of the diverse world of whiskey.