Why is a Wisconsin Old Fashioned different?

Answered by Michael Blake

The Wisconsin Old Fashioned is a unique variation of the classic cocktail that sets it apart from its counterparts in other parts of the country. This distinctive twist on the traditional Old Fashioned has become synonymous with Wisconsin's drinking culture and has gained popularity both within the state and beyond.

One of the key differences in the Wisconsin Old Fashioned lies in the choice of spirit. While the original Old Fashioned typically calls for or , Wisconsin bartenders often use as the base spirit. This substitution gives the cocktail a slightly sweeter and fruitier flavor profile compared to its whiskey-based counterpart. The use of brandy in the Wisconsin Old Fashioned dates back to the Prohibition era when whiskey was harder to come by, and brandy became a popular alternative.

Another notable difference is the muddled fruit used in the Wisconsin Old Fashioned. While the traditional Old Fashioned usually incorporates a simple orange peel garnish, the Wisconsin version goes a step further by muddling a combination of orange slices, cherries, and sometimes even a splash of cherry . This added fruitiness enhances the overall flavor and lends a vibrant hue to the cocktail.

The sweetener used in the Wisconsin Old Fashioned also diverges from the classic recipe. Instead of a sugar cube or simple syrup, bartenders in Wisconsin often opt for a touch of granulated sugar or even a splash of , which adds a subtle sweetness to the drink without overpowering the other flavors. This variation in sweeteners contributes to the cocktail's unique taste and sets it apart from the traditional version.

In Wisconsin, the Old Fashioned is not just a cocktail; it has become a cultural symbol and a source of pride. It is deeply ingrained in the state's history and tradition, with many Wisconsinites having fond memories of enjoying this drink at family gatherings, supper clubs, and local bars. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned has become a symbol of hospitality, community, and the state's love for its own distinct drinking culture.

Furthermore, the Wisconsin Old Fashioned is often served with a variety of garnishes and mix-ins, allowing for a customizable drinking experience. From muddled fruit to maraschino cherries, from soda to lemon-lime soda, each bartender and drink enthusiast may have their own preferred way of preparing and enjoying this beloved cocktail. This versatility and personal touch are what make the Wisconsin Old Fashioned an ever-evolving and individualized drink.

Lastly, the popularity of the Wisconsin Old Fashioned has led to it being considered for recognition as the official State Cocktail of Wisconsin. This proposal not only highlights the significance of the cocktail in the state's culture but also serves as a testament to the pride Wisconsinites have in their unique twist on a classic drink.

The Wisconsin Old Fashioned stands out from its traditional counterpart due to the use of brandy as the base spirit, the inclusion of muddled fruit, the choice of sweetener, and the personalization of garnishes and mix-ins. It has become a symbol of Wisconsin's drinking culture and a source of pride for its residents. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned is not just a cocktail; it is a reflection of the state's history, tradition, and the camaraderie shared over a well-crafted drink.