If you're unable to find Averna amaro for your Black Manhattan cocktail, don't worry! There are several other dark, herbal, and sweet amaros that you can substitute and still create a delicious drink. As an expert sommelier and brewer, I've had the opportunity to experiment with different amaros and have some great recommendations for you.
One excellent alternative to Averna is Meletti amaro. It has a similar dark and rich flavor profile with herbal undertones and a touch of sweetness. Meletti amaro is often used in cocktails such as the Amaro Spritz, where its unique flavors shine. I highly recommend giving it a try in your Black Manhattan.
Another fantastic option is Nonino amaro. This Italian amaro has a complex and robust flavor, with notes of herbs, spices, and a hint of bitterness. It works beautifully in cocktails like the Paper Plane, but it can also be a great substitute for Averna in a Black Manhattan.
If you're looking for another alternative, consider Amaro Tosolini. This amaro has a deep, rich flavor profile with a balanced sweetness and a touch of bitterness. It adds complexity and depth to cocktails, making it a great choice for a Black Manhattan.
Cynar is yet another option worth exploring. Although it has a slightly different flavor profile than Averna, it can still work well in a Black Manhattan. Cynar is known for its artichoke-based bitterness, which adds a unique twist to cocktails. If you're open to experimenting with different flavors, Cynar can be an exciting substitute.
In my personal experience, I've found that each amaro brings its own unique character to a cocktail. While Averna is a popular choice for a Black Manhattan, don't be afraid to explore different options and let your taste preferences guide you. The world of amaros is vast and diverse, offering endless possibilities for creating unique and delicious cocktails.
To summarize, if you can't find Averna amaro for your Black Manhattan, consider substituting it with Meletti, Nonino, Amaro Tosolini, or even Cynar. Each of these alternatives brings its own distinct flavors to the cocktail, allowing you to create a personalized twist on the classic recipe. Cheers to your mixology adventures!