Buffalo Trace and Blanton's are both bourbons, but they do have some differences in terms of flavor profile. In my opinion, Buffalo Trace is lighter and less rich compared to Blanton's. The difference is quite obvious when you taste them side by side.
One noticeable distinction is the level of sweetness. Blanton's has a higher level of sweetness compared to Buffalo Trace. The sweetness in Blanton's is rich and pronounced, with notes of caramel, vanilla, and honey. On the other hand, Buffalo Trace has a more subtle sweetness, with less emphasis on caramel and more on lighter, fruity notes.
In terms of fruitiness, Blanton's definitely has more prominent fruit flavors. I often find notes of ripe berries, cherries, and even a touch of citrus in Blanton's. Buffalo Trace, on the other hand, has a more subdued fruitiness, with hints of orchard fruits like apples and pears.
Another difference I've noticed is the earthiness. Blanton's has a deeper, more pronounced earthiness, with notes of leather, tobacco, and oak. This gives Blanton's a certain complexity and depth. Buffalo Trace, while also displaying some earthy notes, is not as robust in this aspect. I often detect hints of caraway and pumpernickel in Buffalo Trace, which add a subtle earthiness.
I would say that Buffalo Trace feels like the “light” version of Blanton's Gold. It lacks the same level of richness and complexity, but there are still some overlapping flavors that give it a unique character. If you enjoy Blanton's, you may find Buffalo Trace to be a lighter and more approachable alternative.
In my personal experience, I have enjoyed both Buffalo Trace and Blanton's, but I do have a preference for Blanton's when it comes to special occasions or when I want a more indulgent bourbon. However, for everyday sipping or when I'm looking for a lighter option, Buffalo Trace is a great choice. It still offers a pleasant bourbon experience, with its own distinct flavors.
To summarize, Buffalo Trace is similar to Blanton's in some aspects, but it is definitely lighter and less rich. The sweetness, fruitiness, and earthiness are not as pronounced in Buffalo Trace, but there is some overlap in certain flavors. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and the occasion for which you are enjoying the bourbon.