When it comes to finding a substitute for Averna in a Black Manhattan, there are several options available that can provide a similar dark, herbal, and sweet flavor profile. As an expert sommelier and brewer, I have had the pleasure of exploring various amaros and can recommend a few alternatives to Averna.
One great option is Meletti, which we actually used in an Amaro Spritz recipe. Meletti is a delightful amaro with a rich and complex taste, featuring notes of herbs, spices, and an underlying sweetness. It can be a fantastic substitute for Averna in a Black Manhattan, providing a similar depth of flavor and complementing the other ingredients in the cocktail.
Another excellent choice is Nonino, which is often used in a classic cocktail called the Paper Plane. Nonino is a slightly lighter amaro compared to Averna, but it still offers a delightful combination of herbal and sweet flavors. It can bring a unique twist to a Black Manhattan and create an intriguing variation of the cocktail.
If you're looking for another option, Amaro Tosolini is worth considering. This amaro is known for its smooth and velvety texture, with a rich blend of herbs and spices. It shares some similarities with Averna in terms of its dark and sweet profile, making it a suitable substitute for a Black Manhattan.
Cynar is another popular amaro that could work well in a Black Manhattan. It has a distinct artichoke flavor that adds a unique touch to cocktails. While it may not provide the exact same taste as Averna, it can still create an interesting and delicious twist on the classic cocktail.
In my personal experience, I have found that experimenting with different amaros in cocktails can lead to delightful surprises. Each amaro has its own unique character and flavor profile, which can add depth and complexity to a cocktail like the Black Manhattan. Don't be afraid to try different substitutions and see which one resonates with your palate.
To summarize, if you can't find Averna, there are several alternatives you can consider for a Black Manhattan. Meletti, Nonino, Amaro Tosolini, and Cynar are all excellent options that can provide a similar dark, herbal, and sweet profile. Explore and experiment with these amaros to find the perfect substitute for your cocktail.