When it comes to finding a Scotch whisky that is similar to Macallan, there are a few options that come to mind. Macallan is known for its rich, sherry-forward profile, so it's worth looking for whiskies that share similar characteristics. Here are a few options that I would recommend exploring:
1. GlenDronach: GlenDronach is well-known for its heavily sherried whiskies, which make it a great alternative to Macallan. Their whiskies often exhibit similar notes of rich fruitiness, dark chocolate, and spices. The GlenDronach 18 Year Old Allardice is a particularly excellent expression to try.
2. Aberlour: Another distillery that produces whiskies with a strong sherry influence is Aberlour. Their whiskies tend to have a good balance of fruity sweetness, spices, and oak, similar to Macallan. The Aberlour A'Bunadh is a cask strength expression that is highly regarded and offers a powerful sherry experience.
3. Balvenie: While Balvenie is not typically associated with heavy sherry influence like Macallan, they do offer a range of whiskies that have some similarities. The Balvenie DoubleWood, for example, is aged in both traditional oak casks and sherry casks, resulting in a sweet and spicy profile with hints of dried fruits.
4. Glenfarclas: Glenfarclas is a family-owned distillery that has been producing sherry cask matured whiskies for generations. Their whiskies often display a rich and robust sherry influence, with flavors of dark fruits, toffee, and spices. The Glenfarclas 21 Year Old is a fantastic expression to try if you're looking for a Macallan alternative.
5. Glengoyne: Glengoyne is known for its unhurried distillation process and the use of sherry casks in maturation. Their whiskies offer a delicate balance of fruity sweetness, nuttiness, and gentle spices. The Glengoyne 18 Year Old is a great expression to explore if you enjoy Macallan.
It's important to note that while these whiskies share some similarities with Macallan, they also have their own unique characteristics. It's always a good idea to explore different distilleries and expressions to find the one that best suits your palate and preferences. Keep in mind that personal taste plays a significant role in determining which whisky will be your favorite. Experimentation and exploration are key to finding your perfect alternative to Macallan. Cheers!