When it comes to choosing the best vermouth for a classic Manhattan, there are a few factors to consider. The first and most important decision is whether to use sweet vermouth or dry vermouth. While both can work in a Manhattan, sweet vermouth is the traditional choice and adds a rich and slightly sweet flavor to the cocktail.
Now, let's dive into the different options for sweet vermouth. As mentioned earlier, sweet vermouths are typically dark red or brown in color, which sets them apart from the clear and lighter dry vermouths. Two popular brands that offer excellent sweet vermouth options for a Manhattan are Dolin and Carpano Antica.
Dolin, in my opinion, is a fantastic choice for those looking for a softer and smoother vermouth. It has a delicate and refined flavor profile, with a hint of sweetness that is not overpowering. The herbal and botanical notes in Dolin's sweet vermouth are well-balanced, creating a harmonious blend of flavors that complements the other ingredients in a Manhattan.
On the other hand, Carpano Antica is another top contender for the best sweet vermouth in a Manhattan. It has a more robust and full-bodied taste compared to Dolin. The rich and complex flavors of Carpano Antica come from a blend of carefully selected herbs, spices, and wines. It adds depth and intensity to the cocktail, making it a favorite among enthusiasts who enjoy a bolder flavor profile.
Both Dolin and Carpano Antica have their unique characteristics and bring something special to the Manhattan experience. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and the specific flavor profile you are seeking in your cocktail. Some may prefer the smoothness and subtlety of Dolin, while others may enjoy the boldness and complexity of Carpano Antica.
In my own experience, I have found that using Dolin sweet vermouth creates a well-balanced and elegant Manhattan. The softness of the vermouth allows the other ingredients, such as the whiskey and bitters, to shine without overpowering them. It creates a smooth and enjoyable drinking experience, perfect for sipping on a cozy evening.
However, I must note that taste is subjective, and what works for me may not be the same for everyone. I encourage you to explore and experiment with different sweet vermouths to find your own preferred choice for a Manhattan. You may even discover other brands or variations that suit your taste better.
When choosing a sweet vermouth for a classic Manhattan, consider options like Dolin and Carpano Antica. Dolin offers a softer and smoother flavor profile, while Carpano Antica brings a bolder and more complex taste. Ultimately, the best vermouth for a Manhattan depends on personal preference and the desired flavor profile of your cocktail. Cheers!