As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the pleasure of tasting and experiencing both the Red Label and Black Label expressions from Johnnie Walker. Each has its own distinct qualities and it ultimately comes down to personal preference when determining which is better.
The Red Label is known for its bold and spicy flavors, which I find to be quite delightful in cocktails and mixed drinks. The richness and intensity of the Red Label make it a standout choice for those who enjoy a whisky that can hold its ground in a mixed drink. The spiciness adds a kick and complexity to cocktails, making it a popular choice for those who enjoy a bit of a punch in their libations.
On the other hand, the Black Label is known for its smooth, deep, and complex character. The flavors are more nuanced and layered, making it an excellent choice for sipping and savoring. The Black Label has a certain elegance and sophistication that sets it apart from the Red Label. The smoothness of this expression allows the complex flavors to shine through, making it a whisky to be enjoyed slowly and thoughtfully.
In terms of price, the Black Label is slightly more expensive than the Red Label. This is reflective of the additional aging and craftsmanship that goes into creating the Black Label. The extra time spent maturing in oak barrels adds depth and complexity to the whisky, which is reflected in its price point.
Personally, I enjoy both the Red Label and Black Label for different occasions. When I'm in the mood for a bold and fiery cocktail, I reach for the Red Label. Its robust flavors can stand up well to other ingredients and create a memorable drinking experience. On the other hand, when I want to savor a whisky on its own, I opt for the Black Label. Its smoothness and complexity make it a truly enjoyable sipping whisky.
Ultimately, the choice between the Red Label and Black Label comes down to personal preference and the occasion. If you enjoy bold and spicy flavors or plan to use the whisky in cocktails, the Red Label is an excellent choice. However, if you prefer a smooth and complex sipping whisky, the Black Label is the way to go. Both expressions offer their own unique qualities and can provide a memorable drinking experience. It's all about finding the one that suits your taste and preferences.