As an expert sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and compare various Johnnie Walker products, including Swing and Gold Label. In my opinion, Swing is indeed a better choice compared to the newly launched Gold Label, which does not carry an age statement. However, it is important to note that Swing does not quite reach the level of quality and complexity found in the discontinued Gold Label 18 years.
Let me start by discussing the Gold Label range. The newly released Gold Label, without an age statement, leaves much to be desired in terms of depth and character. While it may still possess some of the signature Johnnie Walker flavors, it falls short in comparison to its older counterparts. The lack of an age statement also raises questions about the maturity and complexity of the whiskey, leaving me less inclined to recommend it.
On the other hand, the now discontinued Gold Label 18 years was a standout option in the Johnnie Walker lineup. With its extended aging period, this expression offered a remarkable balance of flavors, richness, and sophistication. The 18-year maturation process allowed for a harmonious integration of the whiskies, resulting in a smooth and velvety texture with layers of complexity. Unfortunately, this gem is no longer available, making it difficult to directly compare it to Swing.
Moving on to Swing, it can be considered a step up from the newly launched Gold Label in terms of quality and enjoyment. Swing is a blended Scotch whisky that incorporates a higher proportion of Highland malts, which contributes to its distinct character. The inclusion of these malts brings forth a subtle sweetness and a touch of floral notes, adding depth and complexity to the overall profile.
In terms of price point, Swing falls below the top-tier offerings like Blue Label and 18-year-old Platinum, making it a more accessible option for those seeking a premium Johnnie Walker experience. While it may not possess the same level of refinement and luxuriousness as these higher-end expressions, Swing still offers a well-rounded and enjoyable drinking experience.
To summarize, while Swing is better than the newly launched Gold Label without an age statement, it does not quite reach the level of excellence found in the discontinued Gold Label 18 years. If given the choice, I would still opt for the 18-year-old Platinum or Blue Label when seeking the pinnacle of Johnnie Walker's offerings. However, Swing remains a solid choice for those looking for a balanced and flavorful blended Scotch whisky at a more affordable price point.