When it comes to comparing the different expressions of Paul John whisky, it's important to consider individual preferences and taste profiles. Each whisky from Paul John Distilleries has its own unique characteristics and flavor profiles, making it difficult to definitively say which one is better. However, I can provide you with a detailed analysis of some of the popular expressions from Paul John Distilleries.
1. Paul John Brilliance: This is the flagship expression of Paul John and is known for its smooth and approachable nature. It is matured in ex-bourbon casks, which impart a subtle sweetness and vanilla notes to the whisky. Brilliance is a great choice for those who prefer a lighter and more delicate whisky with a gentle fruitiness.
2. Paul John Edited: Edited is another popular expression from Paul John, which is known for its peat influence. It is a lightly peated whisky that strikes a balance between the smoky notes and the fruity and malty flavors. The peat smoke in Edited is not overpowering, making it an excellent choice for those who are new to peated whiskies or prefer a milder smoky profile.
3. Paul John Bold: As the name suggests, Bold is a bolder and richer expression from Paul John Distilleries. It is matured in American virgin oak casks, which contribute to its intense flavors of spices, dark chocolate, and oak. Bold is perfect for those who enjoy a full-bodied and robust whisky with pronounced flavors and a long finish.
4. Paul John Peated Select Cask: This expression is for peat enthusiasts who crave a more intense and heavily peated whisky. Peated Select Cask is matured in select casks to enhance the peat smoke flavors, which are reminiscent of bonfires and earthy notes. It offers a complex and smoldering experience for those who appreciate a peat-forward whisky.
5. Paul John Single Cask releases: Paul John also offers limited edition single cask releases, which are highly sought after by whisky connoisseurs and collectors. These expressions showcase the unique characteristics of individual casks, offering a truly exceptional and exclusive whisky experience. The flavor profiles of these single cask releases can vary significantly, depending on the cask type and maturation period.
It is important to note that individual preferences play a significant role in determining which Paul John expression is better. Some might prefer the smoothness and delicacy of Brilliance, while others might enjoy the boldness and richness of Bold or the peat influence in Edited or Peated Select Cask. Exploring and tasting different expressions from Paul John Distilleries can help you discover your personal favorite based on your own taste preferences and experiences.