As an experienced sommelier and brewer, I can say that Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic is indeed similar to bitter lemon, but there are a few distinctions to be made. Originally named Lemon Tonic, Fever-Tree's creation combines the flavors of quinine-flavored tonic water with the addition of lemon juice and rind. This combination gives it a unique taste that is reminiscent of bitter lemon but with a twist.
When it comes to taste, bitter lemon is characterized by its bitter and citrusy flavor profile. It is typically made by combining quinine, lemon juice, and sugar to create a refreshing and tangy drink. Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic, on the other hand, aims to enhance the taste of the classic tonic water by infusing it with natural lemon flavors. The result is a more balanced and subtle lemon taste, which may appeal to those who prefer a milder citrus flavor.
In terms of aroma, both bitter lemon and Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic offer a pleasant and zesty fragrance. The addition of lemon juice and rind in both beverages contributes to the aromatic experience, providing a burst of citrus notes that can be quite invigorating.
While the two beverages share similarities in taste and aroma, it is important to note that Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic is not a direct replica of bitter lemon. The proportions of quinine, lemon juice, and sugar may differ, and Fever-Tree's focus on enhancing the tonic water base sets it apart from traditional bitter lemon drinks.
Furthermore, personal preferences play a significant role in determining which of these beverages one may prefer. Some individuals may enjoy the bold and distinct flavor of bitter lemon, while others may find Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic to be a more refined and balanced option.
In my personal experience, I have found Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic to be a delightful addition to various cocktails. Its subtle lemon flavor complements the botanicals of gin or vodka, allowing the spirit to shine while adding a refreshing citrus twist. However, there are occasions when I still crave the more pronounced bitterness and tanginess of a traditional bitter lemon.
To sum up, while Fever-Tree's Lemon Tonic and bitter lemon share similarities, they are not identical. Fever-Tree's creation offers a more nuanced and refined lemon flavor, making it a versatile option for both standalone enjoyment and cocktail mixing. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on personal preferences and the desired flavor profile for a particular occasion.