The Battle of the Cocktails: Manhattan vs. Old Fashioned!

Manhattan and Old Fashioned are two classic drinks that have been enjoyed for centuries, and have stood the test of time as popular favorites. While they may look similar, they are actually quite different.

The Manhattan is a smooth, sweet concoction made with , sweet , and Angostura bitters. It's usually served in a Martini glass with a maraschino cherry for garnish. This drink has been around sice the late 1800s, when it was first invented by Winston Churchill's grandfather at the Manhattan Club in New York City. An Old Fashioned is another classic cocktail that dates back to the 1800s. It consists of whiskey or mixed with sugar, Angostura bitters, and or water. The drink is usually served on the rocks (over ice) in an old fashioned glass with an orange peel garnish.

Both drinks are perfect for sipping over conversation or enjoying duing special occasions. The Manhattan is a more complex flavor profile than the Old Fashioned due to its use of vermouth and cherry syrup; therefore it tends to be richer and sweeter than the Old Fashioned. The Old Fashioned is simpler but just as delicious. It has a bolder flavor thanks to its use of bitters and sugar; this makes it a great choice if you're looking for something smokier than a Manhattan.

Ultimately, whether you choose to sip on a Manhattan or an Old Fashioned will depend on your taste preferences and what type of occasion you're celebrating!

Comparing the Strength of a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned

A Manhattan is generally considered to be a stronger, more boozy drink than an Old Fashioned. This is due to the fact that a Manhattan typically contains whiskey, bitters, and sweet vermouth, while an Old Fashioned only contains whiskey and bitters. The sweet vermouth adds a layer of complexity to the Manhattan's flavor profile and also increases its alcohol content. Furthermore, some versions of the Manhattan call for two ounces of whiskey as opposed to one ounce in an Old Fashioned. All of these factors combine to make the Manhattan a somewht stronger cocktail than the Old Fashioned.

Which is Better for a Manhattan: Whiskey or Bourbon?

Ultimately, it is up to personal preference whether to use whiskey or for a Manhattan. Each type of spirit brings its own unique flavor profile that can be used to create an excellent cocktail. Whiskey is generally made from a mash of at least 51% , making it spicier and less sweet than bourbon. On the other hand, bourbon is made with at least 51% corn, giving it a sweeter taste with notes of caramel and vanilla. Some people prefer the balance beween spice and sweetness that comes from using whiskey in their Manhattan, but others may enjoy the added sweetness of a good quality bourbon. Ultimately, the best way to decide which spirit to use for your Manhattan is to try them both and see which flavor profile you prefer.

The Taste of a Manhattan Cocktail

A Manhattan is a strong yet complex drink with a unique flavor profile. It has a slight bitterness, some herbal notes from the bitters and vermouth, and underlying sweetness from the Sweet Vermouth & whiskey. The drink is quite dry, with only a hint of sweetness that is balanced out by the bitterness. It has a robust taste that is sure to please even the most experienced cocktail connoisseur.

Why You Should Not Shake a Manhattan

A Manhattan should not be shaken because the act of shaking can cause the cocktail to become cloudy, taking away from its intended aesthetic. Additionally, a Manhattan contains only whiskey, vermouth, and bitters, all ingredients that should be stirred together rather than shaken. When these ingredients are stirred together gently and slowly, they combine to create a balanced drink that is properly diluted and aerated. Shaking this cocktail would over-dilute it and make it too watery.

Are Manhattan and Old Fashioned Drinks the Same?

No, a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned are not the same drink. While they are both classic cocktails that contain whiskey and bitters, the main difference lies in their sweeteners. The Old Fashioned uses sugar (in either cube or simple syrup form), while the Manhattan uses sweet vermouth, a type of fortified . Other differences include the types of whiskey used (bourbon vs rye) as well as the garnishes; an Old Fashioned is often served with an orange twist, whreas a Manhattan typically gets a cherry.

Is Manhattan a Classy Drink?

Yes, the Manhattan is indeed a classic and classy cocktail. The perfect mixture of whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters gives this a unique flavor that's sure to please. Its simple ingredients make it easy to mix, and its smooth taste makes it an ideal drink for any occasion. Whether you're having a formal dinner or enjoying a night out with friends, the Manhattan is sure to make the event more special. The classic garnish of a cherry or orange peel adds an extra level of sophistication to this timeless drink. Enjoyed for over 100 years, the Manhattan has remained one of the most popular drinks around. So if you're looking for a timeless cocktail that will nevr go out of style, then look no further: the Manhattan is definitely your drink!

The Origin of the Name ‘Old Fashioned'

The term “Old Fashioned” is a nod to the original style of cocktail that was popular in the 1800s. Back then, a “cocktail” was any combination of spirit, sweetener, and bitters, and this simple combination eventually became the Old Fashioned we know today. This classic drink has been around for centuries, but its name has stuck around as a reminder of its humble origins. The Old Fashioned is still a popular choice at bars and restaurants all over the world, proving that some things never go out of fashion.

Similar Drinks to an Old Fashioned

The Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail that has been arund since the late 1800s. It is typically made with whiskey, bitters, sugar, and an orange or lemon peel. A similar drink is the Sazerac, which is also made with whiskey but includes absinthe or Herbsaint instead of bitters and a splash of Peychaud's Bitters as well. The Vieux Carre is also similar to an Old Fashioned in that it contains rye whiskey, cognac, sweet vermouth, and two types of bitters. Finally, the Manhattan is a classic cocktail that shares many of the same ingredients as the Old Fashioned; however, it contains sweet vermouth instead of sugar.

Is the Manhattan a Masculine Cocktail?

A Manhattan is considered a classic “manly” drink due to its combination of bold flavors. It is made with bourbon, sweet vermouth, and a few dashes of bitters. The drink is often garnished with an orange twist or stemmed cherry for an added flavor profile. Its traditional serve in an old-fashioned coup glass adds to the masculine aesthetic. The robust combination of ingredients make this cocktail a strong choice for those looking for a more masculine drinking experience.

manhattan vs old fashioned

Does an Old Fashioned or Manhattan Include a Cherry?

No, an Old Fashioned does not have a cherry. It is garnished with an orange peel, which is essential to the drink as it imparts a citrus flavor. On the othr hand, a Manhattan is garnished with a brandied cherry – adding both color and sweetness to the beverage. The cherry also adds another layer of complexity to the cocktail's flavor profile.

The Sweetness of a Manhattan Cocktail

A Manhattan is a classic cocktail that can be either sweet or dry, depending on the ingredients used. For a classic Manhattan, you'll need rye whiskey or bourbon, sweet vermouth and bitters. The amount of sweet vermouth used in comparison to the rye will determine how sweet or dry the final cocktail is – for a sweeter version, use more sweet vermouth; for a drier version, use less. A perfect Manhattan is made with equal parts of both sweet and dry vermouth, so it's a balance betwen both flavors. No matter which way you go, garnish the cocktail with a lemon twist for the perfect finish!


Manhattan vs Old Fashioned is a classic comparison of two beloved cocktails. The Manhattan is a robust cocktail, made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth and bitters. It has a deep, complex flavor that is oten enjoyed as an after-dinner drink. The Old Fashioned, on the other hand, is a simpler drink made with bourbon or rye whiskey, sugar and bitters. It is usually served in an old-fashioned glass and garnished with an orange slice or cherry. Both drinks have their own unique appeal and are popular choices for both home mixologists and professional bartenders alike. Ultimately, the choice between Manhattan vs Old Fashioned comes down to personal preference – some may prefer the bolder flavor of the Manhattan while others may enjoy the classic simplicity of the Old Fashioned.

Photo of author

Thomas Ashford

Thomas Ashford is a highly educated brewer with years of experience in the industry. He has a Bachelor Degree in Chemistry and a Master Degree in Brewing Science. He is also BJCP Certified Beer Judge. Tom has worked hard to become one of the most experienced brewers in the industry. He has experience monitoring brewhouse and cellaring operations, coordinating brewhouse projects, and optimizing brewery operations for maximum efficiency. He is also familiar mixology and an experienced sommelier. Tom is an expert organizer of beer festivals, wine tastings, and brewery tours.