As a sommelier and brewer, I can certainly provide some insight into finding a good substitute for bourbon in a Paper Plane cocktail. The Paper Plane is a delightful and refreshing cocktail that typically calls for bourbon as one of its main ingredients. However, there are several alternatives that you can use if you don't have bourbon on hand or simply prefer a different flavor profile.
1. Rye Whiskey: Rye whiskey can be a fantastic substitute for bourbon in a Paper Plane. Rye whiskey tends to have a spicier and bolder flavor compared to bourbon, which can add an interesting twist to the cocktail. It pairs well with the other ingredients like Amaro Nonino and Aperol, creating a complex and well-balanced drink.
2. Scotch Whisky: If you enjoy smoky and peaty flavors, using a peated Scotch whisky as a substitute for bourbon can be an intriguing option. The smokiness from the Scotch can add a unique dimension to the cocktail, creating a more robust and layered taste experience.
3. Irish Whiskey: Irish whiskey tends to be smoother and lighter in flavor compared to bourbon. While it may alter the overall taste profile of the Paper Plane slightly, it can still make for a delicious variation. The citrus notes in the cocktail can complement the subtle sweetness of Irish whiskey, resulting in a refreshing and well-rounded drink.
4. Apple Brandy: If you're looking for a non-whiskey alternative, apple brandy can be an excellent substitute for bourbon in the Paper Plane. Apple brandy offers a rich and fruity flavor that pairs well with the other ingredients in the cocktail. It adds a touch of sweetness while maintaining the complexity of the original recipe.
5. Reposado Tequila: For those who enjoy tequila, a reposado tequila can be an interesting and unexpected substitute for bourbon in a Paper Plane. The woody and slightly smoky flavors of reposado tequila can complement the herbal notes of the Amaro Nonino and the bittersweetness of the Aperol. This substitution can result in a unique and flavorful twist on the classic cocktail.
When making any substitution, it's important to consider the flavor profile you prefer and how it will interact with the other ingredients in the cocktail. Experimentation is key in mixology, so don't be afraid to try different alternatives and adjust the ratios to suit your taste. Remember, the beauty of cocktails lies in their versatility and ability to adapt to individual preferences. Cheers!