Elijah Craig and Evan Williams are both popular bourbon brands, but they have distinct differences in terms of flavor profile, age, and bottling strength. As a sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and compare both expressions, and I can share my insights with you.
1. Flavor Profile:
Elijah Craig Small Batch is known for its bold and robust flavor profile. It is packed full of intense flavors such as bitter dark chocolate, ginger, and prominent wood tannins. The high concentration of these flavors gives it a complex and intense character, making it a favorite among bourbon enthusiasts who enjoy a more robust and flavorful experience.
On the other hand, Evan Williams is generally described as mellow and easy-going. It has a smoother and more approachable flavor profile compared to Elijah Craig. While it still has hints of oak and spice, the flavors are more balanced and harmonious. Evan Williams is often praised for its rich caramel and vanilla notes, which make it a popular choice for those who prefer a smoother and more relaxed bourbon drinking experience.
2. Age:
Another notable difference between Elijah Craig and Evan Williams is the age of the bourbon. Elijah Craig Small Batch is aged between 8-12 years, which contributes to its intense flavor profile and complexity. The extended aging process allows the bourbon to develop deeper flavors and aromas from the oak barrels. This longer aging period is often associated with higher quality and a more refined taste.
On the other hand, Evan Williams is aged for a shorter period of time, typically around 5-7 years. While it is still considered a well-aged bourbon, the shorter aging process results in a slightly less mature flavor profile compared to Elijah Craig. However, this also means that Evan Williams is more affordable and accessible to a wider range of bourbon enthusiasts.
3. Bottling Strength:
Elijah Craig Small Batch is bottled at 47% ABV (alcohol by volume), which is higher than the typical 40% ABV found in many other bourbons. The higher bottling strength contributes to the bold and intense flavors found in Elijah Craig. It also allows the bourbon to hold up well when mixed in cocktails, providing a robust and flavorful base.
On the other hand, Evan Williams is typically bottled at the standard 40% ABV. This lower bottling strength results in a smoother and more approachable drinking experience. It is also worth noting that Evan Williams offers a range of expressions, including higher proof options for those who prefer a stronger and more intense bourbon.
The main differences between Elijah Craig and Evan Williams lie in their flavor profile, age, and bottling strength. Elijah Craig Small Batch is known for its intense and robust flavors, aged between 8-12 years, and bottled at a higher ABV. On the other hand, Evan Williams offers a mellow and easy-going flavor profile, aged for a shorter period, and typically bottled at a standard 40% ABV. Both bourbons have their unique characteristics and cater to different preferences, so it ultimately comes down to personal taste and preference.