Can you use simple syrup instead of gomme syrup?

Answered by Ian Ramirez

As a sommelier and brewer, I have experimented with various sweeteners in , including both simple syrup and gomme syrup. While simple syrup is the go-to sweetener for many bartenders today, gomme syrup offers a unique viscosity and mouthfeel that can elevate certain cocktails to a whole new level.

Gomme syrup, also known as gum syrup, is made by dissolving gum arabic, a natural gum derived from the sap of the acacia tree, into a simple syrup solution. This process creates a thicker and more viscous syrup compared to regular simple syrup. The addition of gum arabic not only increases the viscosity but also imparts a subtle silky texture to the syrup.

One of the main advantages of using gomme syrup is its ability to provide a richer and more velvety mouthfeel in cocktails. This enhanced texture can be particularly beneficial in classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned or the Sazerac, where the syrup plays a crucial role in balancing the flavors. The added body and viscosity of gomme syrup can help to create a smoother and more harmonious drink.

Furthermore, gomme syrup has a longer shelf life compared to simple syrup. The gum arabic acts as a natural stabilizer, preventing the syrup from crystallizing or spoiling over time. This extended shelf life makes gomme syrup a convenient option for bartenders who want to prepare larger batches in advance or for home enthusiasts who don't want their syrup to go to waste.

However, it is important to note that gomme syrup is not always necessary or suitable for every cocktail. Some drinks require a lighter and more delicate sweetness, where simple syrup is sufficient. Additionally, the use of gomme syrup may alter the balance and overall flavor profile of certain cocktails, so it's essential to consider the specific drink you are making and how the syrup will affect its taste.

In my personal experience, I have found that gomme syrup works exceptionally well in classic -based cocktails like the Whiskey Sour or the . The added viscosity of the syrup creates a luscious mouthfeel that complements the bold flavors of the . However, when making a lighter and refreshing cocktail like a or a Tom Collins, I tend to stick with simple syrup to maintain the crispness and brightness of the drink.

While gomme syrup offers a unique texture and extended shelf life, it is not always necessary or appropriate for every cocktail. Simple syrup can be a suitable substitute in many cases, providing a lighter and more straightforward sweetness. Ultimately, the choice between gomme syrup and simple syrup depends on the specific cocktail you are making and the desired mouthfeel and flavor profile you wish to achieve.