As an expert sommelier and brewer, I have had the opportunity to taste and analyze various spirits and liqueurs. When it comes to comparing Kraken and Captain Morgan, it ultimately boils down to personal preference. However, in my experience, I found Captain Morgan to be the better choice.
Firstly, in terms of smoothness, Captain Morgan takes the lead. The texture of the rum is velvety and goes down the throat with ease. On the other hand, while Kraken is not necessarily rough, it lacks the same level of smoothness that Captain Morgan offers. The latter seems to have a more refined and polished quality to it.
Additionally, the cherry flavor in Captain Morgan is more subtle and well-balanced. It doesn't overpower the overall taste of the rum but rather adds a hint of sweetness and complexity. In comparison, Kraken's attempt at a cherry flavor feels a bit forced and artificial. It has a distinct liquorice note that can be quite distracting and doesn't blend seamlessly with the other flavors in the rum.
Furthermore, I believe that Captain Morgan has a broader appeal due to its versatility. It can be enjoyed on its own, mixed in cocktails, or even used in cooking and baking. The smoothness and balanced flavors make it a more versatile option for various occasions. On the other hand, Kraken's liquorice note might restrict its suitability for certain cocktail recipes or flavor pairings.
I must emphasize that taste is subjective, and some individuals may prefer the distinct liquorice note in Kraken. However, based on my expertise and personal experiences, Captain Morgan emerges as the superior choice. Its smoothness, subtle cherry flavor, and overall versatility make it a more enjoyable and well-rounded rum. Ultimately, I encourage you to try both options and see which one suits your palate and preferences best.